| Club Domestic | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Premier League | Winner | 3x | 1958/1959, 1957/1958, 1953/1954 |
| Runner-up | 5x | 1959/1960, 1954/1955, 1949/1950, 1938/1939, 1937/1938 | |
| Championship | Winner | 3x | 2008/2009, 1976/1977, 1931/1932 |
| Runner-up | 2x | 1982/1983, 1966/1967 | |
| FA Cup | Winner | 4x | 1959/1960, 1948/1949, 1907/1908, 1892/1893 |
| Runner-up | 4x | 1938/1939, 1920/1921, 1896/1897, 1888/1889 | |
| League Cup | Winner | 2x | 1979/1980, 1973/1974 |
| Community Shield | Winner | 2x | 1959/1960, 1954/1955 |
| Runner-up | 3x | 1960/1961, 1958/1959, 1949/1950 | |
| Club International | |||
| UEFA Europa League | Runner-up | 1x | 1971/1972 |
