| Club Domestic | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Premier League | Winner | 1x | 1919/1920 |
| Runner-up | 2x | 1953/1954, 1924/1925 | |
| Championship | Winner | 3x | 2007/2008, 1910/1911, 1901/1902 |
| Runner-up | 5x | 2009/2010, 2003/2004, 2001/2002, 1948/1949, 1930/1931 | |
| FA Cup | Winner | 5x | 1967/1968, 1953/1954, 1930/1931, 1891/1892, 1887/1888 |
| Runner-up | 5x | 1934/1935, 1911/1912, 1894/1895, 1886/1887, 1885/1886 | |
| League Cup | Winner | 1x | 1965/1966 |
| Runner-up | 2x | 1969/1970, 1966/1967 | |
| Community Shield | Winner | 1x | 1920/1921 |
| Runner-up | 3x | 1968/1969, 1954/1955, 1931/1932 | |
