Goalkeeper Adam Collin was the hero as Rotherham United beat Leyton Orient 4-3 on penalties to seal promotion to the Championship on Sunday.
Rotherham initially came from two goals down to rescue a 2-2 draw at Wembley, only to then fall behind in a shoot-out as a result of Lee Frecklington's saved effort.
Yet Collin kept out spot-kicks from Mathieu Baudry and Chris Dagnall to lift the New York Stadium outfit into the second tier of English football for the first time since the 2004-05 season.
Russell Slade's men raced into a 2-0 lead against a Rotherham side who were well below their best in the first half.
Moses Odubajo broke the deadlock with a superb strike just after the half-hour mark - hitting a vicious shot that left Collin with no chance.
And Orient were two up before the break when Odubajo latched on to a weak headed clearance from James Tavernier to square for Dean Cox to tap in.
However, former Orient striker Alex Revell inspired a second-half fightback with two goals, the second a stunning effort to send the tie to extra time.
And after coming from behind in normal time, Rotherham successfully did so again in the shoot-out - Collin's save from Dagnall sending fans from South Yorkshire into raptures.
A crowd of 43,401 did not have to wait long for a moment of controversy as Revell went down under a challenge from Nathan Clarke inside the area.
Referee David Coote waved the protests away as Rotherham continued to dominate the early exchanges.
However, Evans' men were dealt two blows before the break as Odubajo's fierce hit put Orient on top before Cox added a second to put his side in a comfortable position.
If Slade's side thought they could coast to victory from there, Rotherham had other ideas, going close with a Ben Pringle free-kick shortly after the interval.
Revell showed his poaching ability to pull one back 10 minutes into the second half with a close-range prod before delivering a goal to outshine Odubajo's earlier effort.
Following an aerial challenge from a long ball, Revell took control and hit a half-volley from well outside the area to restore parity on the hour.
Jones was forced into a reaction save in the first additional period when Scott Cuthbert carelessly headed in the direction of his own goal, but that was as close to either side came to preventing penalties, which eventually went the way of Steve Evans' men.
|11||M. Odubajo||34' 35'|
|Coach: R. Slade|
for D. Cox 74'
for K. Lisbie 76'
for D. Mooney 105'
|Dembele can do anything - Tuchel|
|Pogba arrival would boost Rooney - Yorke|
|Ben Yedder makes Sevilla move|
|De Jong signs PSV renewal until 2020|
|Kovacic to fight for his place at Real Madrid|
|Sturridge out to improve goals-per-game ratio|
|Mourinho hails ´humble´ Ibrahimovic ahead of United debut|
|Schweinsteiger will not leave Manchester United for Bundesliga return - Rummenigge|
|Benatia on target again in Juve win|
|Atletico set to sign Gameiro|
|Zenga appointed Wolves boss|
|Flattered Verratti not seeking Madrid move|
|Ancelotti: Growing transfer fees nothing special|
|Eriksson: Ibrahimovic and Mourinho combo enough to win Premier League|
|Meunier: I could not reject PSG|
|Klopp: I didn´t want Mkhitaryan|
|Anything could happen before transfer window shuts - Zidane|
|Montoya leaves Barca base, nears Valencia switch|
|Wijnaldum: I´m happy to play anywhere|
|Klopp backs Mignolet after Karius injury|
|Liverpool suffer Karius injury blow|
|Ranieri confident Mahrez will stay as contract talks continue|
|Emery confirms interest in Jese|
|Higuain´s Juventus move not about money - agent|
|Wolves sack head coach Jackett|
|Zidane: Ronaldo unlikely to play Madrid La Liga opener|
|Ibrahimovic: United fans are waiting for me|
|Deulofeu shines for Everton, Cook opens Bournemouth account|
|Higuain out to emulate Del Piero|
|Kante does his talking on the pitch - Conte|
|Mourinho explains Fosu-Mensah snub|
|Klopp: No more unwanted players at Liverpool|
|Inter want more than €60m for Icardi - Thohir|
|Leicester can replace Kante - Ranieri|
|Lazio complete Wallace signing|
|Gueye set to join Everton, confirms Di Matteo|
|Tuchel: Transfer market has gone cash crazy|
|Leicester hand King new four-year deal|
|No deal done for Pogba, says Raiola|
|Rooney: Mourinho impact already huge|
|Lafferty hit with FA betting charge|
|Top-four finish never enough for Arsenal, insists Wenger|
|Partey hoping to make his mark on Atletico squad|
|Ibrahimovic in, Schweinsteiger out as United head for Galatasaray friendly|
|Vietto set for Sevilla after completing medical|
|I rejected Besiktas to fight for Barcelona spot, reveals Mathieu|
|De Laurentiis fumes at Higuain´s ´lack of respect´|
|Promising Janssen boosts Tottenham´s title hopes|
|Besiktas sign Adriano on three-year contract|
|Tottenham 0 Atletico Madrid 1: Godin grabs the winner|
|Gomis completes Marseille loan move|
|Iniesta surprised at Casillas-Del Bosque spat|
|New Juve signings do not guarantee success - Allegri|
|New Juve signings do not guarantee success - Allegri|
|Middlesbrough snap up goalkeeper Guzan|
|Guardiola still loves Ribery despite jibes|
|West Ham worry over Tore injury|
|Serie A could be another one-horse race, says Eriksson|
|Schweinsteiger retires from Germany duty|
|Iniesta welcomes Barca´s midfield competition|
|Drogba: No luck in Arsenal scoring record|
|Wenger seeks ´experienced´ striker to bolster Arsenal attack|
|Eriksson and Shanghai SIPG still fighting|
|MLS All-Stars 1 Arsenal 2: Premier League giants win late as Xhaka makes debut|
|Conte: I want aggression and intensity|
|Wimmer backs physical Janssen for Tottenham success|
|Klopp: I wouldn´t spend £100m on one player|
|Sampaoli: Taking Argentina job would be irresponsible|
|Payet absence no excuse - Noble|
|Gabriel Jesus expects Palmeiras exit amid Manchester City rumours|
|Domzale 2 West Ham 1: Crnic double stuns Bilic´s side|
|Juventus target Gabriel Barbosa says Santos exit is close|
|Leicester duo ready for ´once in a lifetime´ Champions League journey|
|Fabregas apologises for Klavan lunge|
|Reschke: Guardiola wanted Tuchel to be his successor|
|Pochettino expecting further Tottenham signings|
|Given retires from international football|
|Abdi and Pudil swap Watford for Wednesday|
|Leicester sign Chilwell to new five-year deal|
|Klopp pre-season ´most intense ever´ for Sturridge|
|Simeone backs Griezmann for Ballon d´Or final three|
|Puskas Award winner quits football - to become a gamer|
|Simeone: Champions League final felt like a death|
|Higuain: I have to prove my worth to Juventus|
|Guardiola confirms interest in Sane and Stones|
|Moreno set for Manchester City switch and Deportivo loan, claims agent|
|De Laurentiis pushed me into Juventus move - Higuain|
|Savic seeking to put injury woe behind him|
|Borussia Dortmund 1 Manchester City 1 (5-6 pens): Gunn´s shootout saves earn Guardiola first win|
|Oblak: Atleti need consistency and luck|
|Warburton rubbishes Van Persie rumours|
|Hospitalised Grujic ´can´t remember anything´, says Klopp|
|Premier League, Serie A appeal to Simeone|
|Copa Libertadores success ´a dream´ for Borja|
|Pochettino honoured by Simeone comparisons|
|Argentina have not asked for Sampaoli - Monchi|
|Ancelotti: Fitness the key for Bayern|
|Bayern win ´a small foundation´ for Montella´s Milan|
|Icardi missing due to injury - Mancini|
|Emery satisfied with warm-up win over Madrid|
|Conte quiet on Tevez, apologises for Fabregas red|
|´It was far from a friendly´ - Klopp on Chelsea defeat|
|Madrid off the pace, concedes Zidane|
|Chelsea 1 Liverpool 0: Cahill´s header seals win|
|Grujic says Chelsea´s Matic told him to sign for Liverpool|
|Bolasie wants to see Berahino and Benteke at Crystal Palace|
|Rodgers hails ´outstanding result´ as Celtic draw|
|Walcott claims level of MLS is close to Premier League|
|Bayern Munich 3 AC Milan 3 (3-5 on penalties): Bonaventura seals win|
|Atletico Nacional 1 Independiente del Valle 0 (2-1 agg): Borja secures Copa Libertadores crown|
|Icardi absent again as Inter held by Estudiantes|
|Real Madrid 1 Paris Saint-Germain 3: Zidane oversees poor pre-season start|
|Hazard vows to rediscover best Chelsea form|
|Klopp reveals why he sent Sakho back to Liverpool|
|Tevez: Conte wanted me at Chelsea|
|Sunderland hopeful Defoe will be fit for Man City opener|
|Sundowns overcome Zamalek to book semi-final spot|