Stephane M'Bia's 94th-minute header broke Valencia hearts as Sevilla progressed to the UEFA Europa League final on away goals on Thursday.
The Cameroon international – on loan from Queens Park Rangers - nodded home deep into second-half stoppage time, giving Sevilla a 3-1 defeat on the night.
And that was enough to send his side through on away goals despite Valencia's brave fightback.
M'Bia, who scored in Sevilla's 2-0 first-leg win, rose highest at the near post to finish past Valencia goalkeeper Diego Alves after Coke's long throw was flicked on by Federico Fazio.
Sevilla will have been well aware of Valencia's never-say-die attitude after Juan Antonio Pizzi's men overturned a 3-0 deficit to emerge as 5-3 victors in their quarter-final tie with Basel.
And that spirit was evident as Sofiane Feghouli halved the aggregate deficit 14 minutes in.
Jonas' header - from a Juan Bernat cross - was then deflected over the line by goalkeeper Beto after it hit the underside of the crossbar.
Defender Jeremy Mathieu scooped into the roof of the net in the 70th minute to give his side the lead but they were to be denied, as M'Bia's last-gasp effort booked Sevilla a final showdown with Benfica in Turin on May 14.
The hosts were without the suspended Paco Alcacer - scorer of a hat-trick in his side's sensational win against Basel last month - but Valencia still started brightly, with Jonas prodding an effort at Beto in the first two minutes.
Carlos Bacca scored the second in last week's first leg and he had a great chance to open the scoring this time around, only to skew wide of the target in the eighth minute.
It was the home side who would take the early lead, though, as Feghouli exchanged passes with Eduardo Vargas before showing great composure to cut inside Fazio and drive home via a slight deflection.
The Algeria international continued to wreak havoc, forcing Beto into a save after battling his way through the visiting defence, and Valencia were level in the tie in the 26th minute.
Bernat whipped in a sublime cross from the left for Jonas to meet with his head, and his powerful effort was tipped onto the woodwork by Beto.
The ball then rebounded onto the goalline before eventually crossing the line off the keeper's back to send the Mestalla crowd wild.
Jose Antonio Reyes should have restored Sevilla's aggregate advantage nine minutes before the break, but his sliding effort from close range was superbly saved by goalkeeper Alves after Bacca's backheel across the face of goal.
Chances dried up in the second half, with extra time looking an increasingly likely prospect, but Mathieu had other ideas with 20 minutes remaining.
The centre-back reacted quickest when the ball fell loose from a corner, with his smart finish firing Valencia in front.
Sevilla applied some late pressure, knowing that just a single goal would prove enough, but chances were at a minimum.
That was until M'Bia's telling impact, though, as Sevilla reached the final of Europe's secondary club competition for the first time since 2007, when they lifted the trophy.
|Porto 2 Penafiel 0: Danilo scores in farewell game|
|La Liga Preview: Eibar, Almeria hoping for final-day salvation|
|Eredivisie play-offs: Go Ahead suffer surprise defeat, NAC win|
|South Africa warm up for COSAFA Cup with victory|
|Rodriguez will be like a new signing - Adkins|
|Renard leaves Ivory Coast role amid Lille speculation|
|Howedes doubtful for start of next Bundesliga campaign|
|Deschamps: Pogba and Evra will be happy to face Albania|
|Everton v Tottenham: Pochettino eyeing fifth spot|
|Crystal Palace v Swansea City: Pardew admits to talent envy|
|Van Gaal confident of keeping De Gea|
|Spurs to support Adebayor over family issues|
|Manchester City v Southampton: Koeman expects no favours from hosts|
|Chelsea v Sunderland: Champions set to finally lift trophy|
|Mancini: Inter need quality|
|Van Gaal: No favours for ex-United captain Bruce|
|Leicester City v QPR: Ramsey expects doomed Rangers to show pride|
|Koeman expecting quieter close season|
|Hughes delivers positive update on Bojan|
|Advocaat considering Sunderland offer|
|Hull City v Manchester United: Bruce accepts survival is tall order|
|Stoke City v Liverpool: Rodgers keen to move focus away from Sterling|
|Allardyce won´t let us down, says Bruce|
|Berahino can leave for top-four club - Pulis|
|Aston Villa v Burnley: Sherwood wanting win ahead of cup final|
|Big clubs would be making a ´mistake´ signing Bolasie|
|Peterborough announce Robertson as new manager|
|Relieved Sherwood eager to kick on|
|Newcastle United v West Ham: Carver dreading ´unbearable´ drop|
|Pellegrini unsure over Milner future|
|I am not good enough to win treble every year - Guardiola|
|Luis Enrique refuses to be drawn on Barca future|
|Ntep handed France call-up|
|Allegri compares Juve to class of 2003|
|My future to be decided on Monday - Allardyce|
|Ancelotti expects to stay at Real despite speculation|
|Play-off finals to go ahead despite discovery of World War II bomb|
|Mourinho lauds ´legend´ Lampard|
|Milan v Torino: Shadow of Ancelotti hangs over Inzaghi|
|Speroni extends Palace contract|
|Ramsey issues QPR warning|
|Valverde signs new Bilbao contract|
|Welbeck could miss FA Cup final and England double header|
|League One play-off final Preview: Preston hoping to end hoodoo|
|Rodgers expects Sterling talks to resume|
|Martinez dismisses Oviedo exit talk|
|Neil hoping to draw on previous play-off success|
|Cisse weighing up offers from USA, India and Poland|
|Hazard announced as Premier League´s Player of the Season|
|United should sign Cech if De Gea leaves - Scholes|
|Copa Libertadores Review: Cruzeiro draw first blood away from home|
|MLS Preview: Wondolowski poised for 100-goal club|
|Ligue 1 Preview: Monaco, Marseille, Saint-Etienne battle for Champions League spot|
|Bundesliga Preview: Relegation battle set for dramatic end, Dortmund to farewell Klopp|
|Serie A Preview: Radu in doubt for crucial Rome derby|
|Stankovic denies talk of Inter return|
|Benitez would be ´happy´ to manage Real - agent|
|Newcastle not expecting favours from Allardyce - Carver|
|Lacazette can be ´world class´ - Houllier|
|Hodgson defends Sterling|
|Eredivisie Review: Heerenveen and Vitesse seize initiative|
|Prince Ali confirms World Cup expansion plans|
|Giroud hits back at ´dull´ Henry over Arsenal comments|
|Real Madrid v Getafe: Ancelotti banned in potential Bernabeu farewell|
|Stoke secure permanent Wollscheid deal|
|Ligue 1 relegation places cut to two|
|Bayern Munich v Mainz: Champions out to ring in title with return to form|
|Granada v Atletico Madrid: Tiago ready for difficult final day|
|Luis Figo statement on FIFA president candidacy withdrawal|
|Barcelona v Deportivo La Coruna: Xavi prepares to bid farewell to La Liga|
|New Liverpool deals for Ibe and Flanagan|
|The tooth hurts for Hazard as he looks set to miss Sunderland clash|
|Juventus v Napoli: Double winners prepare to celebrate|
|Luis Figo withdraws from FIFA presidency race|
|Bielsa not expecting contract offer from Marseille|
|Hodgson: No England rift with United over Shaw|
|Genoa v Inter: Mancini´s men chase European berth|
|Borussia Dortmund v Werder Bremen: Klopp looks to sign off with European qualification|
|Bartomeu hits out at Ancelotti to Barca rumours|
|Paris Saint-Germain v Reims: Parisians ready to celebrate title triumph|
|I have not spoken to any clubs, insists Klopp|
|League Two play-off final Preview: Ainsworth claims underdog status|
|Sheringham named Stevenage boss|
|Lawless banned for football betting|
|Defence should be United´s priority, says Stam|
|Klopp vows to ignore nostalgia at final home game|
|Hodgson excited by new England call-ups|
|Xavi: Barca will survive without me|
|Benzema sustains hamstring injury|
|Maiden England call-ups for Austin, Vardy and Heaton|
|Kramer relishing Leverkusen return|
|Xavi confirms Barcelona departure|
|Sterling ´definitely not signing´ new Liverpool deal - agent|
|Herrera eyes second-season improvement|
|Kane plans long Tottenham stay|
|Schmidt signs new Leverkusen deal|
|Sterling should stay at Liverpool, says Redknapp|
|Van Praag withdraws from FIFA presidential race|
|Financial fair play here to stay, warns Platini|
|Zidane: Gerrard and me are alike|
|Drobny ruled out of Hamburg finale|
|Defoe: We want Advocaat to stay|
|Zorc expects Hummels to stay|
|Wilshere happy with position|
|Moreno talks up Europa League|
|Santa Fe 1 Internacional 0: Mosquera nets injury-time winner|
|Sporting Kansas City 4 New England Revolution 2: Nemeth inspires victory|
|Dunga calls up Fred, Felipe Anderson for Olympic trials|
|Koke wants to be Atleti´s Gerrard|
|Tinkler: FFA are ripping off owners|
|Klopp will excel at big club - Feulner|
|Allegri concedes cards fell Juve´s way|
|Estoyanoff cops six-game ACL ban for punching|
|Desailly: Mourinho would have won title with City|
|Teary Advocaat delighted to silence the Sunderland doubters|
|Pioli bemoans Lazio´s lack of luck|
|Chiellini salutes Juve fight after Coppa triumph|