Carlo Ancelotti's calls for a Real Madrid response to El Clasico fell on deaf ears as a 2-1 loss to Sevilla damaged their Liga hopes again.
Real's controversial 4-3 defeat to arch-rivals Barcelona at the Bernabeu on Sunday saw them overtaken by Atletico Madrid at the table's summit - subsequently reigniting the Catalans' own challenge in what is shaping up to be one of the best Spanish title races in recent years.
But Ancelotti's side endured more disappointment in Andalusia on Wednesday, with a second reverse in the space of a few days.
Cristiano Ronaldo's 14th-minute free-kick gave them a good start and they looked rampant at one stage, with Karim Benzema in particular threatening.
However, they were made to rue their misses as Carlos Bacca levelled a few moments later.
The visitors enjoyed far more of the ball than Sevilla in the second half, but Bacca's contribution was decisive, as he netted a second with 18 minutes to go to give the hosts the points.
Former Sevilla defender Sergio Ramos and Angel Di Maria missed the trip to Andalusia due to their respective suspensions and the latter's replacement – Asier Illarramendi – played a crucial role in the first minute.
Vicente Iborra knocked Ivan Rakitic's free-kick delivery back across goal and Federico Fazio looked destined to nod in, but Illarramendi hooked the ball away.
The opening stages continued in a similarly breathless fashion and Benzema spurned two big chances - first slotting Dani Carvajal's cut-back just wide, before heading Ronaldo's free-kick off target.
However, the Ballon d'Or winner's next set-piece provided the breakthrough.
After earning a free-kick just outside the Sevilla area, Ronaldo's effort deflected off the arm of Bacca and sailed past the helpless Beto for a 14th-minute lead.
The home side hit back five minutes later, though, as Bacca latched on to Jose Antonio Reyes' throughball and coolly poked the ball past Diego Lopez.
Ronaldo almost doubled his tally and restored the Madrid advantage in the 43rd minute, but his close-range looping effort struck the post, before Nico Pareja hacked clear off the line.
The match appeared to lack flow in the second period, but that seemed to suit the visitors more as they dominated proceedings against Unai Emery's tiring Sevilla.
However, Real struggled to create clear-cut scoring chances and their insistence on crossing into the area played right into the hands of their hosts, with Fazio continually heading clear.
And despite Real's domination, Sevilla forged ahead in the 72nd minute.
Rakitic produced a brilliant first touch to evade Pepe before racing down the left flank and sliding a pass through to Bacca, who confidently slotted through Lopez's legs.
Ancelotti’s men desperately pressed for a late way back, but their efforts went without reward as Sevilla held on for sixth straight La Liga win, leaving Real three points behind leaders Atletico at the top.
|19||José Antonio Reyes|
|9||C. Bacca||19' 72'|
|Coach: Unai Emery|
for M. Marin 71'
for José Antonio Reyes 75'
for C. Bacca 83'
|Simeone: Casemiro the key for Real|
|Mourinho urges United to ´forget the past three years´|
|Malaga appoint Ramos|
|Berlusconi ready to relinquish power at AC Milan|
|Busquets agrees new five-year Barcelona contract|
|Euro 2016 not under threat from strike action - Braillard|
|Real Madrid v Atletico Madrid: San Siro the stage for Champions League final re-run|
|Vela staying with Sociedad - agent|
|A poke in the eye & ´the f****** master´: Five of the best Mourinho v Guardiola battles|
|Red Devils enter Faustian pact as Manchester United hire Mourinho|
|Star striker top of Mourinho´s United shopping list|
|An attacking mastermind even more fearsome than Ferguson - Jose Mourinho in numbers|
|Manchester United appoint Mourinho as manager|
|Italy not among Euro 2016 favourites - Ancelotti|
|Win or lose in Milan, it is time for Perez to back Zidane|
|Ronaldo wants Morata back at Madrid|
|England v Australia preview: All eyes on Rashford debut|
|Weigl, Kimmich grateful to Tuchel and Guardiola|
|Benitez: I´m ready for Championship challenge|
|Colombia v Haiti: Bacca ready for responsibility|
|Karembeu hails Zidane ahead of Champions League final|
|Panama v Brazil: Lucas Lima ready to prove himself|
|Kaka replaces Douglas Costa in Brazil´s Copa America squad|
|Mascherano opens up on Juventus rumours|
|Allen unclear over Liverpool future|
|Hodgson praises scrapped cup replays|
|Deschamps to take legal action against Cantona|
|Kuyt signs new Feyenoord deal|
|Messi set for court appearance on June 2|
|Juninho tips Atletico for Champions League glory|
|Galatasaray 1 Fenerbahce 0: Podolski header settles Turkish Cup final|
|Skrtel set for Liverpool exit|
|Rashford set for England debut|
|Xavi: It is Atletico Madrid´s time to win the Champions League|
|Manchester United will be hard to beat with Mourinho - Courtois|
|Signing ´animal´ Ibrahimovic a no-brainer for Man Utd, says Henry|
|FA Cup quarter-final replays scrapped|
|Cantona suggests Deschamps dropped Ben Arfa and Benzema over race|
|Depay ´p***** off´ at lack of football|
|Ferdinand welcomes Mourinho to Manchester United|
|Delph placed on England standby list|
|Wales talisman Bale shrugs off Euro pressure|
|Ronaldo open to working under Mourinho again|
|Ronaldo values Champions League over Barcelona´s double|
|Switzerland v Belgium: Shaqiri eyes Euro glory|
|Willian: Manchester United stronger with Mourinho|
|Liverpool and Dortmund in for Guerreiro|
|Real Madrid will attack Atletico again, says Ancelotti|
|Ramirez set for Southampton exit|
|Bale calls for cool Madrid heads|
|´Mourinho can take United back to the top´ - Ibrahimovic hints at Old Trafford switch|
|Hull City v Sheffield Wednesday: Promotion windfall the prize on offer|
|Lahm eyes Champions League glory with Ancelotti|
|Juventus chief hints at Dani Alves deal|
|Gotze warned he will not be first choice under Ancelotti|
|Courtois: If nothing strange happens, I will continue at Chelsea|
|Vermaelen ´disappointed´ by Barca struggles|
|Higuain and Lamela dream of lifting the Copa America|
|Reborn Torres returns to Milan to complete Atletico´s greatest tale|
|Lukaku offers Everton ultimatum: I want to win trophies!|
|United States v Bolivia: Copa America hosts to fine-tune preparations|
|Zidane has united Real Madrid again - Ramos|
|Mexico v Paraguay: Marquez ready to make the most of ´great opportunity´|
|Republic of Ireland v Netherlands Preview: O'Neill wants confident display|
|Coyle leaves Houston Dynamo|
|McLaren could end Mercedes dominance - Alonso|
|Orlando City 2 Philadelphia Union 2: Tribbett rescues point in controversial contest|
|United States 1 Ecuador 0: Last-gasp Nagbe goal lifts hosts in Copa America warm-up|
|Djourou compares Xhaka to Pirlo|
|Gallas ´very proud´ of former boss Ranieri´s title glory|
|Copa America to use goal-line technology|
|Smith likens Postecoglou to Klopp|
|Hart backs Sterling to shine at Euro 2016|
|Giovinco happy in MLS despite Euro 2016 snub|
|Balotelli set for Liverpool return, confirms Berlusconi|
|Atletico must win Champions League - Cerezo|
|Arbeloa: Mourinho didn´t get enough recognition at Madrid|
|Mijatovic: Bale can save Madrid´s season in Champions League final|
|Gallas expects Conte to revive Chelsea|
|Deschamps ´annoyed, but not worried´ by Varane´s absence|
|´Impossible´ to see MSN leaving Barcelona - Bartomeu|
|Thiago pledges future to Bayern|
|Uruguay v Trinidad and Tobago: Sanchez skips final to help Suarez-less La Celeste|
|AFC Champions League Review: Urawa pay the penalty as Seoul advance|
|Uruguay v Trinidad and Tobago: Sanchez skips final to help Suarez-less La Celeste|
|Benitez ´convinced´ he can win trophies at Newcastle|
|Nigeria v Mali: Moses among many absentees for hosts|
|Chile - Jamaica Preview: Copa plans crystallize in Vina del Mar|
|Nigeria v Mali: Moses among many absentees for Super Eagles|
|Benitez to stay at Newcastle|
|Kramaric leaves Leicester for Hoffenheim permanently|
|Neustadter gets green light for Russia Euro 2016 selection|
|Chile v Jamaica: Copa plans crystallize in Vina del Mar|
|Ledley making progress in bid to prove Euro 2016 fitness|
|Gotze returns to Germany training|
|Ronaldo: Madrid would be smart to give me a new deal|
|Northern Ireland v Belarus: Last chance to impress as O'Neill prepares to trim squad|
|Varane disappointed by Euros absence|
|Republic of Ireland v Netherlands: O´Neill wants confident display|
|Ronaldo shakes off injury in Real Madrid training|
|Atletico star Griezmann ´listening to different clubs´|
|United States - Ecuador Preview: Klinsmann pins hopes on Yedlin as Copa preparations continue|
|Gold tells Middlesbrough to ´dream on´ over Antonio|
|Schweinsteiger wants Mourinho to spice up Manchester derby|
|England v Australia: All eyes on Rashford debut|
|Aggressive Premier League better for me - Xhaka|
|Schweinsteiger ´right on schedule´ for Euro 2016|
|Darmian relishing Euros after return from injury|
|Northern Ireland v Belarus: Last chance to impress as O´Neill prepares to trim squad|
|Ventura leaves Torino amid Italy talk, Mihajlovic appointed|
|Sevilla confident of keeping Emery|
|Godin wants Atletico to use 2014 defeat as inspiration|
|Xhaka agrees Arsenal move|
|Idolisation of Ibrahimovic warranted Sweden captaincy - Hamren|
|Scholes hopes Mourinho keeps Giggs at Manchester United|
|Gotze snubbing Liverpool will boost Germany - Bierhoff|
|Bosz honoured by Ajax appointment|
|Ramos highlights Griezmann threat|
|Record-chasing Ronaldo and taming the Wolves - Real Madrid´s route to the Champions League final|
|Donnarumma dreams of being Milan captain|
|Koke: History, not revenge motivating Atletico|
|Costa Rica v Venezuela: Hosts ramp up preparations for maiden Copa America tilt|
|Argentina v Honduras: Messi and co warm up for Copa America|
|USA will win a World Cup, says Donovan|
|Pumas UNAM 2 Independiente del Valle 1 (3-3 agg, 3-5 on penalties): Hosts suffer shoot-out heartbrea|
|Gracia leaves Malaga as Rubin Kazan loom|
|Messi: Argentina deserve to be Copa America champions|
|Dybala included in Argentina´s preliminary Olympics squad|
|Mourinho and United a ´good wedding´ - Ancelotti|
|Klinsmann: Copa America better than Euros|
|Messi: Joining Barcelona not an easy decision|
|Carrico receives four-game ban for homophobic slur|
|Dani Alves wants Atletico to win Champions League|
|McNair out to impress ´world-class´ Mourinho|
|Ranieri: Premier League survival is Leicester´s priority next season|