Giacomo Bonaventura's late header continued Inter's Atalanta hoodoo as the visitors secured a dramatic 2-1 win at San Siro on Sunday.
In a result that extends Atalanta's winning run to four Serie A games, Bonaventura scored twice, with his winning goal coming after withstanding a second-half barrage from Inter.
However, Inter's profligacy and Bonaventura's brace proved crucial as the hosts missed the chance to move ahead of fourth-placed Fiorentina, who make the trip to Napoli later on Sunday.
After an entertaining start that saw visiting captain German Denis head against the crossbar, the opening two goals came within the space of two late first-half minutes.
Expert finishes from Bonaventura and Mauro Icardi ensured the sides went in level at the break before Inter twice struck the woodwork early in the second half.
Inter, though, failed to make the most of their chances and Bonaventura made them pay - heading home in the 90th minute to extend Inter's winless run against Atalanta to six matches.
With Walter Mazzarri's Inter going in search of a third straight victory, Hernanes played in Fredy Guarin for the game's first opportunity - the Colombian placing an effort marginally wide of Andrea Consigli's left-hand post.
The two combined again shortly after, but this time Guarin opted for power, as he fired over the crossbar.
Samir Handanovic was then required to keep out powerful efforts from Guglielmo Stendardo and Luca Cigarini as he demonstrated some of the form that had seen Inter keep clean sheets in their previous three outings.
Guarin's third effort stung the palms of Consigli before Icardi failed to provide a cutback for Rodrigo Palacio when played in behind the Atalanta defence.
Bonaventura's long-range strike dipped too late to threaten Handanovic before he eventually found the net at the third attempt after 35 minutes.
Following a quick break, Bonaventura made the most of Denis' decoy run to create space before firing past Handanovic.
However, Atalanta's joy was shortlived, as a minute later Icardi collected Guarin's slipped pass before cutting inside his marker and firing home the equaliser to restore parity nine minutes before the break.
As in the first half, Inter began on the front foot after the interval with Guarin at the centre of their attacking threat - firing a shot from distance that clipped the crossbar and went over.
Palacio was then denied by the post as he glanced Jonathan's cross over the helpless Consigli as Inter continued to pile on pressure.
However, Stefano Colantuono's charges secured a dramatic late win thanks to Bonaventura's fifth league goal of the season as Inter's European aspirations were dealt a blow.
|Coach: W. Mazzarri|
for E. Cambiasso 61'
for D. D'Ambrosio 72'
for H. Campagnaro 82'
|LFP plans legal action after games suspended|
|Doyle to join Rapids by month´s end|
|MLS Preview: Red Bulls, City to contest first New York derby|
|Real Salt Lake 0 Los Angeles Galaxy 0: Goalkeepers dominate after lightning delay|
|Copa Libertadores Review: Guarani, Sao Paulo in box seat|
|Subotic wants Europa League spot|
|Ligue 1 Preview: Cabaye challenges leaders PSG|
|Bayern ´threw the game away´ against Barcelona - Boateng|
|Sevilla favourites tag motivation for Fiorentina - Montella|
|Cuadrado needs time - Bacca|
|Guardiola: Bayern didn´t lose because of Messi|
|Luis Enrique hails team performance after Messi masterclass|
|Muller hopeful of second-leg fightback in Munich|
|Ribery set to miss Bayern´s second leg with Barca|
|Messi is impossible to describe, says Mascherano|
|Barcelona 3 Bayern Munich 0: Messi lives up to Guardiola´s billing to put Barca on brink of final|
|Spanish federation to suspend all competitions from May 16|
|AFC Champions League Review: Jeonbuk cruise into last 16 but Seongnam crash out|
|McClaren reiterates commitment to Derby amid Newcastle speculation|
|League One play-offs preview: Grayson grateful for Preston´s second chance|
|Belfodil agrees Parma contract termination|
|Sevilla still on track - Emery|
|Duff has Upton Park red card overturned|
|Alexis Sanchez can be as good as he wants - Zamorano|
|Torino 0 Empoli 1: Padelli howler proves costly|
|Real Madrid top Forbes list for third straight year|
|Arnesen backs ´champion´ Van Gaal for success at United|
|McCarthy robbed at gunpoint|
|Paris Saint-Germain v Guingamp: Champions out to pile pressure on Lyon|
|Benitez agent to meet with De Laurentiis|
|Chelsea´s ´boring´ style not an issue - Arnesen|
|Ramos laments poor Turin display|
|Southampton to place trust in academy - Reed|
|Bale not listening to failed managers - agent|
|Bigirimana believes relegation could be good for Newcastle|
|Chelsea still hungry for Liverpool win - Matic|
|Bournemouth to invest in players before stadium|
|Police visit Sports Direct over Rangers investigation|
|Guard of honour should spark Liverpool - Lallana|
|Liverpool to sign teenage Portuguese star|
|Thiago would´ve stayed at Barca under Pep|
|Copa Libertadores Review: Tigres advance to quarters|
|Houston Dynamo 0 San Jose Earthquakes 1: Kinnear claims triumphant Texas return|
|Martinez: Everton got carried away during unbeaten run|
|Neymar has flourished with captaincy - Dunga|
|A-League Preview: Victory, City to meet in biggest Melbourne derby|
|Ramos: Real Madrid in box seat|
|´Bale gave Real nothing´ - Keane|
|Hill backs Ramsey for QPR job|
|Ancelotti confident of Real revival|
|Allegri rues late Llorente miss in Juve triumph|
|Juve sent a warning - Pirlo|
|Inverness Caledonian Thistle 2 Dundee United 1: Ofere and Williams keep European dream alive|
|Juventus 2 Real Madrid 1: Spot-on Tevez earns first-leg lead|
|Sturridge hip surgery a success|
|Coloccini calls for unity as Newcastle target survival|
|Doumbia cleared to make Milan trip|
|Harper calls for Hull unity|
|Guardiola not distracted by Barca homecoming|
|No defence can stop Barca star Messi - Guardiola|
|Neuer ready to face Barca strike trio|
|Napoli v Dnipro: Benitez seeks to make experience count|
|Jones ready for United return|
|Injury rules Oscar out of Brazil´s Copa squad|
|Mazinho proud ahead of Barca v Bayern contest|
|Sevilla v Fiorentina: Kolodziejczak confident ahead of semi-final test|
|Skipper Soriano set for Villarreal return|
|Martinez wary of Pienaar risk|
|AFC Champions League Review: Holders Western Sydney out due to last-gasp Seoul winner|
|Barca focused ahead of Pep return - Luis Enrique|
|Messi has ´no problem´ with Luis Enrique|
|Relegated Tranmere appoint Brabin|
|Ujah agrees Werder transfer|
|Magath backs Guardiola to remain at Bayern|
|Mathieu out of Bayern clash|
|Burnley appeal Duff dismissal|
|Setif drawn in Algeria-heavy Champions League group|
|Terry calls for new Drogba deal|
|Saul agrees bumper Atletico deal|
|Arsenal need to finish season strongly - Wenger|
|New Bilbao deal for Gurpegi|
|Pepe puts Morata friendship aside for Champions League match-up|
|Terry: Too long between titles|
|Hazard can be as good as Messi, Ronaldo - Fabregas|
|Carlisle ´deeply ashamed´ about suicide attempt|
|Tevez planning to win Champions League with Juve|
|Blatter ´knows absolutely nothing´ - Maradona|
|Allegri: Ancelotti a smart man|
|Sunderland academy coach to manage Oldham|
|Primeira Liga Review: Braga secure Europa League berth|
|Bruce backing Hull to respond against Burnley|
|Almeria 2 Celta Vigo 2: Bifouma, Zongo inspire hosts´ comeback|