Giacomo Bonaventura's late header continued Inter's Atalanta hoodoo as the visitors secured a dramatic 2-1 win at San Siro on Sunday.
In a result that extends Atalanta's winning run to four Serie A games, Bonaventura scored twice, with his winning goal coming after withstanding a second-half barrage from Inter.
However, Inter's profligacy and Bonaventura's brace proved crucial as the hosts missed the chance to move ahead of fourth-placed Fiorentina, who make the trip to Napoli later on Sunday.
After an entertaining start that saw visiting captain German Denis head against the crossbar, the opening two goals came within the space of two late first-half minutes.
Expert finishes from Bonaventura and Mauro Icardi ensured the sides went in level at the break before Inter twice struck the woodwork early in the second half.
Inter, though, failed to make the most of their chances and Bonaventura made them pay - heading home in the 90th minute to extend Inter's winless run against Atalanta to six matches.
With Walter Mazzarri's Inter going in search of a third straight victory, Hernanes played in Fredy Guarin for the game's first opportunity - the Colombian placing an effort marginally wide of Andrea Consigli's left-hand post.
The two combined again shortly after, but this time Guarin opted for power, as he fired over the crossbar.
Samir Handanovic was then required to keep out powerful efforts from Guglielmo Stendardo and Luca Cigarini as he demonstrated some of the form that had seen Inter keep clean sheets in their previous three outings.
Guarin's third effort stung the palms of Consigli before Icardi failed to provide a cutback for Rodrigo Palacio when played in behind the Atalanta defence.
Bonaventura's long-range strike dipped too late to threaten Handanovic before he eventually found the net at the third attempt after 35 minutes.
Following a quick break, Bonaventura made the most of Denis' decoy run to create space before firing past Handanovic.
However, Atalanta's joy was shortlived, as a minute later Icardi collected Guarin's slipped pass before cutting inside his marker and firing home the equaliser to restore parity nine minutes before the break.
As in the first half, Inter began on the front foot after the interval with Guarin at the centre of their attacking threat - firing a shot from distance that clipped the crossbar and went over.
Palacio was then denied by the post as he glanced Jonathan's cross over the helpless Consigli as Inter continued to pile on pressure.
However, Stefano Colantuono's charges secured a dramatic late win thanks to Bonaventura's fifth league goal of the season as Inter's European aspirations were dealt a blow.
|Coach: W. Mazzarri|
for E. Cambiasso 61'
for D. D'Ambrosio 72'
for H. Campagnaro 82'
|Inzaghi finds positives in lacklustre display|
|Eredivisie Review: AZ move third, Propper fires Vitesse to victory|
|Chievo 0 Milan 0: Pressure back on Inzaghi|
|Bundesliga Review: Derby win for Dortmund superheroes, Leverkusen go fourth|
|Ligue 1 Review: Lyon loss leaves door open for PSG|
|Bueno nets perfect hat-trick in four-goal spree for Rayo|
|Carver impressed with Newcastle´s fighting spirit|
|Van Gaal explains Di Maria decision|
|Luis Enrique angered by Granada pitch|
|Sherwood confident of Villa survival|
|Referee East says ´no mistaken identity´ as Poyet pledges to look again|
|League One Review: Robertson and Johnson off to winning starts, Bristol City go eight clear|
|Bruce angered by missed decision|
|Berahino can be ´top class´ - Pulis|
|Grateful Gutierrez thanks ´special´ fans|
|Monk targets Swansea points record|
|Klopp´s ´perfect´ afternoon|
|Victory soured by Ireland injury, says Hughes|
|Championship Review: Middlesbrough´s opportunity missed as Derby are defeated|
|Koeman: I am realistic on Champions League|
|League Two Review: Burton beaten again, Hartlepool gain welcome lift|
|´Triple punishment´ rule could be scrapped|
|Scottish Premiership Review: Inverness slip up as strugglers prosper|
|Mancini wary of Fiorentina quality|
|Hearts attack hits double figures in Scotland|
|West Brom 1 Southampton 0: Berahino wins it, then limps off|
|Manchester United 2 Sunderland 0: Rooney at the double amid red card controversy|
|Newcastle United 1 Aston Villa 0: Cisse strike downs visitors|
|Stoke City 1 Hull City 0: Super sub Crouch secures win|
|Granada 1 Barcelona 3: Suarez inspires routine win|
|Burnley 0 Swansea City 1: Trippier own goal proves decisive|
|Borussia Dortmund 3 Schalke 0: Late show seals dominant derby win|
|Referee Dowd fails to make it through West Brom, Saints clash|
|Allardyce ´shocked´ after home loss|
|Pardew lauds Murray after ´mixed afternoon´ for striker|
|West Ham 1 Crystal Palace 3: Pardew enjoys more away-day success|
|Blanc: PSG prepared for confident Monaco|
|Ancelotti: Isco place is non-negotiable|
|Pellegrini out to end dismal record at Anfield|
|Roma v Juventus: Matri eyes glory in title tussle|
|Martinez wary of wounded Arsenal|
|A-League Review: Spectacular Sydney derby the highlight|
|Perez to testify in corruption case|
|Bentaleb determined to avoid European hangover|
|Liverpool cannot dwell on Europa exit, says Rodgers|
|Marquinhos welcomes Manchester United interest|
|Tottenham must be ´nearly perfect´ to beat Chelsea - Pochettino|
|Bielsa: I take responsibility|
|League Cup final ´most important´ for Mourinho|
|Rodgers unsure if European exit will be a blessing|
|Vitoria Guimaraes 1 Maritimo 0: Hosts end winless run|
|Guardiola satisfied with Cologne victory|
|Espanyol 1 Cordoba 0: Abraham goal secures the points|
|Marseille 2 Caen 3: Hosts throw lead away yet again|
|Bayern Munich 4 Cologne 1: Champions move 11 points clear|
|Dordrecht 2 Go Ahead Eagles 1: Klaiber leaves it late|
|Luis Enrique laments English ´campaign´ over Suarez|
|Atletico Madrid v Sevilla: Champions attempt to bounce back|
|De Gea dismisses ´lies´ about Van Gaal relationship|
|Monaco v Paris Saint-Germain: Jardim wants no Champions League distractions|
|Inter v Fiorentina: Both sides on a high after Europa League success|
|Real Madrid v Villarreal: Ancelotti´s side looking to keep chasing pack at bay|
|Arsenal v Everton: Hurting Wenger calls for immediate response|
|Hull and Panathinaikos among four clubs pay FFP fines|
|Liverpool v Manchester City: Champions eye long-awaited Anfield success|
|Lucas Moura out for at least four weeks|
|Chelsea v Tottenham: Mourinho´s men channel spirit of 2005|
|Loan move to Ipswich an easy decision for Wood|
|Qatar World Cup final no later than December 18 - Blatter|
|Martinez excited by Kiev draw|
|Dynamo face disciplinary hearing after crowd trouble|
|Hughes close on signing new Stoke deal|
|Parma game called off again|
|De Boer to stay at Ajax|
|Arnesen backs Vieira as potential future City director of football|
|Mourinho has no fears over Wembley referee|
|Van Persie absent for Sunderland clash|
|Mason hoping to relive 2008 at League Cup final|
|Fiorentina and Roma to meet in Europa League|
|Inter finalise Felipe swoop|
|Poyet delighted to have ´contagious´ Cattermole back|
|Melbourne City 3 Adelaide United 1: Baharudin triggers crucial comeback|
|Chelsea can cope with Matic absence - Terry|
|Mancini: I tried to take Guarin to Galatasaray|
|Wilshere undergoes ankle procedure|
|Bruce: Most Championship clubs would struggle with FFP|
|Henry would say yes to Arsenal job|
|Mignolet backs ´devastated´ Liverpool to regroup|
|Tiote looks set to miss the rest of the season|
|Copa Libertadores Review: Osvaldo scores for Boca, Internacional win|
|Alajuelense 5 DC United 2: Costa Ricans set for semis|
|Besiktas settled score with Liverpool - Cenk|
|Montella: Hard to keep Salah|
|Martinez salutes Everton´s qualification|
|Europa League games marred by crowd trouble|