Giacomo Bonaventura's late header continued Inter's Atalanta hoodoo as the visitors secured a dramatic 2-1 win at San Siro on Sunday.
In a result that extends Atalanta's winning run to four Serie A games, Bonaventura scored twice, with his winning goal coming after withstanding a second-half barrage from Inter.
However, Inter's profligacy and Bonaventura's brace proved crucial as the hosts missed the chance to move ahead of fourth-placed Fiorentina, who make the trip to Napoli later on Sunday.
After an entertaining start that saw visiting captain German Denis head against the crossbar, the opening two goals came within the space of two late first-half minutes.
Expert finishes from Bonaventura and Mauro Icardi ensured the sides went in level at the break before Inter twice struck the woodwork early in the second half.
Inter, though, failed to make the most of their chances and Bonaventura made them pay - heading home in the 90th minute to extend Inter's winless run against Atalanta to six matches.
With Walter Mazzarri's Inter going in search of a third straight victory, Hernanes played in Fredy Guarin for the game's first opportunity - the Colombian placing an effort marginally wide of Andrea Consigli's left-hand post.
The two combined again shortly after, but this time Guarin opted for power, as he fired over the crossbar.
Samir Handanovic was then required to keep out powerful efforts from Guglielmo Stendardo and Luca Cigarini as he demonstrated some of the form that had seen Inter keep clean sheets in their previous three outings.
Guarin's third effort stung the palms of Consigli before Icardi failed to provide a cutback for Rodrigo Palacio when played in behind the Atalanta defence.
Bonaventura's long-range strike dipped too late to threaten Handanovic before he eventually found the net at the third attempt after 35 minutes.
Following a quick break, Bonaventura made the most of Denis' decoy run to create space before firing past Handanovic.
However, Atalanta's joy was shortlived, as a minute later Icardi collected Guarin's slipped pass before cutting inside his marker and firing home the equaliser to restore parity nine minutes before the break.
As in the first half, Inter began on the front foot after the interval with Guarin at the centre of their attacking threat - firing a shot from distance that clipped the crossbar and went over.
Palacio was then denied by the post as he glanced Jonathan's cross over the helpless Consigli as Inter continued to pile on pressure.
However, Stefano Colantuono's charges secured a dramatic late win thanks to Bonaventura's fifth league goal of the season as Inter's European aspirations were dealt a blow.
|Coach: W. Mazzarri|
for E. Cambiasso 61'
for D. D'Ambrosio 72'
for H. Campagnaro 82'
|O´Neill hails ´perfect night´|
|Northern Ireland 3 Belarus 0: Lafferty marks 50th cap with goal|
|Rashford seizes England chance to leave Sturridge in peril|
|England 2 Australia 1: Remarkable Rashford strikes on debut|
|Champions League final: Thankless tasks on eve of showpiece, pesky sprinklers and a few old pros|
|Germany v Slovakia: Low´s young stars desperate to earn Euro call|
|Nigeria 1 Mali 0: Iheanacho ends wretched run|
|Republic of Ireland 1-1 Netherlands: Boys in Green pegged back after Long goal|
|No fears for Real as Ronaldo looks razor sharp|
|Hazard hints at Chelsea stay|
|Reinartz retires at 27 due to injuries|
|Bellerin not interested in rumours of Barcelona move|
|Zidane happy to fulfil Ancelotti´s prophecy|
|Ronaldo is 100 per cent fit for Champions League final - Zidane|
|Rummenigge: Bayern ready to welcome Hoeness back|
|Bordeaux name Gourvennec as new coach|
|Portugal v Norway: Quaresma challenges hosts to prove Euro 2016 ambition|
|Espanyol announce Galca exit|
|Spain v Bosnia-Herzegovina: Uncapped duo aim to impress|
|Middlesbrough confirm Fischer deal|
|Pearson targeting promotion after Derby appointment|
|England 2-1 Australia: Rashford and Rooney see off Socceroos|
|FIFA hits Croatia with stadium ban as part of widespread homophobia sanctions|
|Northern Ireland 3-0 Belarus: O'Neill's men cruise to victory|
|Italy v Scotland: Chiellini spots chance to prepare for Ireland challenge|
|Sane brushes off talk of Schalke exit|
|Yorke: Giggs should be Mourinho successor|
|Defence can lead Italy to Euro success - Chiellini|
|Scolari swoons over ´spectacular´ Ronaldo|
|Neuer to miss Germany friendly|
|Gabi looking forward, not back|
|Gerhardt agrees Wolfsburg switch|
|Champions League final is the game of my life - Torres|
|Simeone: Casemiro the key for Real|
|Mourinho urges United to ´forget the past three years´|
|Malaga appoint Ramos|
|Berlusconi ready to relinquish power at AC Milan|
|Busquets agrees new five-year Barcelona contract|
|Euro 2016 not under threat from strike action - Braillard|
|Real Madrid v Atletico Madrid: San Siro the stage for Champions League final re-run|
|Vela staying with Sociedad - agent|
|A poke in the eye & ´the f****** master´: Five of the best Mourinho v Guardiola battles|
|Red Devils enter Faustian pact as Manchester United hire Mourinho|
|Star striker top of Mourinho´s United shopping list|
|An attacking mastermind even more fearsome than Ferguson - Jose Mourinho in numbers|
|Manchester United appoint Mourinho as manager|
|Italy not among Euro 2016 favourites - Ancelotti|
|Win or lose in Milan, it is time for Perez to back Zidane|
|Ronaldo wants Morata back at Madrid|
|England v Australia preview: All eyes on Rashford debut|
|Weigl, Kimmich grateful to Tuchel and Guardiola|
|Benitez: I´m ready for Championship challenge|
|Colombia v Haiti: Bacca ready for responsibility|
|Karembeu hails Zidane ahead of Champions League final|
|Panama v Brazil: Lucas Lima ready to prove himself|
|Kaka replaces Douglas Costa in Brazil´s Copa America squad|
|Mascherano opens up on Juventus rumours|
|Allen unclear over Liverpool future|
|Hodgson praises scrapped cup replays|
|Deschamps to take legal action against Cantona|
|Kuyt signs new Feyenoord deal|
|Messi set for court appearance on June 2|
|Juninho tips Atletico for Champions League glory|
|Galatasaray 1 Fenerbahce 0: Podolski header settles Turkish Cup final|
|Skrtel set for Liverpool exit|
|Rashford set for England debut|
|Xavi: It is Atletico Madrid´s time to win the Champions League|
|Manchester United will be hard to beat with Mourinho - Courtois|
|Signing ´animal´ Ibrahimovic a no-brainer for Man Utd, says Henry|
|FA Cup quarter-final replays scrapped|
|Cantona suggests Deschamps dropped Ben Arfa and Benzema over race|
|Depay ´p***** off´ at lack of football|
|Ferdinand welcomes Mourinho to Manchester United|
|Delph placed on England standby list|
|Wales talisman Bale shrugs off Euro pressure|
|Ronaldo open to working under Mourinho again|
|Ronaldo values Champions League over Barcelona´s double|
|Switzerland v Belgium: Shaqiri eyes Euro glory|
|Willian: Manchester United stronger with Mourinho|
|Liverpool and Dortmund in for Guerreiro|
|Real Madrid will attack Atletico again, says Ancelotti|
|Ramirez set for Southampton exit|
|Bale calls for cool Madrid heads|
|´Mourinho can take United back to the top´ - Ibrahimovic hints at Old Trafford switch|
|Hull City v Sheffield Wednesday: Promotion windfall the prize on offer|
|Lahm eyes Champions League glory with Ancelotti|
|Juventus chief hints at Dani Alves deal|
|Gotze warned he will not be first choice under Ancelotti|
|Mexico v Paraguay Preview: Marquez ready to make the most of 'great opportunity'|
|Courtois: If nothing strange happens, I will continue at Chelsea|
|Vermaelen ´disappointed´ by Barca struggles|
|Higuain and Lamela dream of lifting the Copa America|
|Reborn Torres returns to Milan to complete Atletico´s greatest tale|
|Lukaku offers Everton ultimatum: I want to win trophies!|
|United States v Bolivia: Copa America hosts to fine-tune preparations|
|Zidane has united Real Madrid again - Ramos|
|Mexico v Paraguay: Marquez ready to make the most of ´great opportunity´|
|Republic of Ireland v Netherlands Preview: O'Neill wants confident display|
|Coyle leaves Houston Dynamo|
|McLaren could end Mercedes dominance - Alonso|
|Orlando City 2 Philadelphia Union 2: Tribbett rescues point in controversial contest|
|United States 1 Ecuador 0: Last-gasp Nagbe goal lifts hosts in Copa America warm-up|
|Djourou compares Xhaka to Pirlo|
|Gallas ´very proud´ of former boss Ranieri´s title glory|
|Copa America to use goal-line technology|
|Smith likens Postecoglou to Klopp|
|Hart backs Sterling to shine at Euro 2016|
|Giovinco happy in MLS despite Euro 2016 snub|
|Balotelli set for Liverpool return, confirms Berlusconi|
|Atletico must win Champions League - Cerezo|
|Arbeloa: Mourinho didn´t get enough recognition at Madrid|
|Mijatovic: Bale can save Madrid´s season in Champions League final|