Argentina reached the FIFA World Cup final as Netherlands coach Louis van Gaal failed to produce another penalty masterstroke.
Having introduced goalkeeper Tim Krul off the bench to replace number one Jasper Cillessen in the quarter-final shoot-out win against Costa Rica - with the Newcastle shot-stopper subsequently saving two spot-kicks to send his side through - Van Gaal had no such options this time around as Wednesday's semi-final finished 0-0 after extra time.
The Dutch had used all three substitutes by that point, leaving Cillessen to face Argentina's efforts when it mattered most.
And the youngster - who had never before kept out a penalty in his career - failed to reproduce his team-mate's heroics as opposite number Sergio Romero saved from Ron Vlaar and Wesley Sneijder to book Argentina's place in the showpiece against Germany on Sunday.
Ultimately, Maxi Rodriguez sealed a 4-2 shoot-out success, crashing his penalty in off the crossbar via the palms of Cillessen to spark jubilant scenes among the South Americans in the stands in Sao Paulo.
In a contest that was a far cry from the stunning drama of Germany's humiliation of Brazil 24 hours earlier, penalties always seemed the most likely outcome and so it proved.
The last time these two teams met in the knockout stages of a finals - in 1998 - the game was lit up by the sublime quality of Dennis Bergkamp's winning goal, but such moments of outstanding individual brilliance were almost non-existent here.
Much of the build-up was dominated by talk of a battle for supremacy between the two sides' respective talismen, but both Lionel Messi and Arjen Robben were well shackled throughout.
With many neutrals having hoped for a Brazil-Argentina final, the capitulation of the hosts on Tuesday meant that was a distant dream, but the success of Alejandro Sabella's men at least ensures that there will be South American representation in the showpiece.
The Dutch, runners-up four years ago, will now face a wounded Brazil in the third-place play-off in Brasilia on Saturday.
In stark contrast to the first semi, where Germany had raced into a 5-0 lead within 29 minutes to stun the hosts, what unfolded a day on was far less enthralling.
Netherlands made one change from their quarter-final win over Costa Rica as Nigel de Jong - who it was thought had been ruled out of the tournament with a groin strain - made an unexpected recovery to return in place of Memphis Depay.
For Argentina, Marcos Rojo came back from a one-match suspension, and Enzo Perez earned a spot in the absence of the injured Angel di Maria.
Neither side carved out a clear goalscoring opportunity in a turgid first period, Sneijder firing an effort on goal in the 13th minute, but his volley from outside the box was comfortably wide of the left-hand post.
Messi threatened for the first time two minutes later, seeing his free-kick well held by Cillessen diving low to his right.
Argentina looked marginally the more dangerous of the two sides and midway through the first half Ezequiel Garay headed Ezequiel Lavezzi's left-wing corner over the crossbar under pressure from Vlaar.
There was a moment of concern for Argentina shortly afterwards, when a clearly dazed Javier Mascherano fell to the floor following a clash of heads with Georginio Wijnaldum.
After receiving treatment, Mascherano was able to walk off the field and soon returned to action.
The second period began in much the same fashion as the first, with neither side able to make any inroads in the final third of the field.
Gonzalo Higuain did have half an opening in the 58th minute, but substitute Daryl Janmaat's covering header denied the Napoli man the chance to get on the end of Lavezzi's delivery from the right.
Once again, Higuain was unable to capitalise on a rare sight of goal 15 minutes from time, stretching to divert Perez's clever low ball into the side netting from close range.
Rojo tried his luck from distance nine minutes later, but his well-hit drive was straight at an untroubled Cillessen.
Robben's big moment arrived in the first minute of stoppage time as he bore down on goal following a fortuitous ricochet on the edge of the area, but Mascherano recovered brilliantly to deny the Bayern Munich man with a last-ditch tackle.
The winger had the first effort of note in extra-time, bringing a routine save out of Romero with a dipping effort from 25 yards after a trademark darting run off the right flank.
There were two late chances for Sabella's men in the final five minutes of the extra period, but both Rodrigo Palacio and Rodriguez failed to gain sufficient power on their efforts to really test Cillessen.
But, with Krul watching on from the sidelines this time, there was little that the young Dutch goalkeeper could do to prevent a clinical Argentina booking their place in the final when the spot-kicks arrived, as first Vlaar and then Sneijder proved wayward before Rodriguez struck the decisive blow.
|3||S. de Vrij|
|4||B. Martins Indi||45'|
|6||N. de Jong|
|9||R. van Persie|
|Coach: L. van Gaal|
for B. Martins Indi 46'
for N. de Jong 62'
for R. van Persie 96'
|Chapecoense to be named Copa Sudamerica champions - Tozzo|
|Bilic: We are in a relegation fight|
|Aubameyang: I don´t know if I´ll be at Dortmund next season|
|Southgate hopes to convince Zaha to play for England|
|Goals will return for Higuain, says Allegri|
|Watford fan dies after falling ill during West Brom clash|
|Simeone will go to Inter, says son Giovanni|
|Simeone marvels at ´almost perfect´ Espanyol defence|
|Gestifute publishes ´Ronaldo tax compliance´|
|Marquinhos urges PSG to forget defeat|
|Tributes paid at Arena Conda memorial after Chapecoense tragedy|
|Juventus 3 Atalanta 1: Alex Sandro stunner helps Allegri´s side return to winning ways|
|Atletico Madrid 0 Espanyol 0: Simeone´s men fail to capitalise on rivals´ slip-ups|
|Metz-Lyon abandoned after Lopes hurt by firecracker|
|Wenger hails ´classy´ Sanchez after 14-minute hat-trick|
|´A big humiliation´ - Bilic slams West Ham´s lack of dedication|
|´Can always count on Serge´ - Bale reacts to El Clasico|
|Modric: Clasico draw feels like a win|
|Record-breaking Leipzig back on top thanks to Kolasinac own goal|
|West Ham 1 Arsenal 5: Sanchez hat-trick sends Gunners second|
|Fellaini: Mourinho more fun than Van Gaal|
|Hughes delighted with Muniesa and Walters impact|
|Goal-shy Messi failing to fire in Clasico clashes|
|Late Clasico draw has little bearing on title race - Zidane|
|Iniesta defends Arda after clumsy foul costs Barca Clasico win|
|Pardew wants Palace to build on Southampton win|
|Mazzarri slams referee Scott after Watford loss|
|´Barca very far off looking like champions´ - Luis Enrique frustrated by Clasico collapse|
|Conte: Chelsea players did well to remain calm|
|Forget Ronaldo - Ramos proves he is Madrid´s ultimate big-game player with Clasico heroics|
|Barcelona were the better team in El Clasico - Suarez|
|Ranieri accepts Leicester face relegation battle|
|Abuse in British football: Chelsea´s statement of apology in full|
|Conte admits Chelsea got lucky|
|Chelsea issue ´profuse apology´ to Johnson following sex abuse claims|
|Reus and Dembele catch Tuchel´s eye in ´complete´ Dortmund performance|
|Montpellier 3 Paris Saint-Germain 0: Visitors miss chance to go top|
|Tottenham needed a big victory - Pochettino|
|´I don´t know if it´s a fair result´ - Ramos accepts Real Madrid rode their luck|
|Barcelona 1 Real Madrid 1: Ramos snatches Clasico point to keep Zidane´s side in control of title ra|
|West Brom 3 Watford 1: Pulis´ men climb into top six|
|Sunderland 2 Leicester City 1: Moyes´ men make it three wins in four|
|Tottenham 5 Swansea City 0: Kane celebrates new deal with brace|
|Crystal Palace 3 Southampton 0: Benteke double and Saints gifts boost Pardew|
|Stoke City 2 Burnley 0: Hughes´ men continue strong run with straightforward win|
|Setback puts Butland injury return on hold|
|Borussia Dortmund 4 Borussia Monchengladbach 1: Aubameyang at the double as Tuchel´s men run riot|
|We had enough chances to win - Guardiola|
|Costa breathes sigh of relief as De Bruyne and Man City misfire|
|Manchester City 1 Chelsea 3: Blues complete brilliant turnaround in Etihad thriller|
|Sevilla miss chance to pile pressure on Clasico rivals with shock loss|
|´It´s not like we´re playing Real Madrid´ - Spalletti confident Roma can beat Lazio|
|Spanish authorities to take ´appropriate´ steps after Ronaldo tax evasion allegations|
|Inter´s Ranocchia sees room for improvement|
|A League Review: City play out feisty Roar draw after FFA Cup exploits|
|Nainggolan has no regrets over failed Chelsea move|
|Arsenal to make decision on Cazorla future in January|
|Bacca has no case to answer for Sevilla trip - Montella|
|Fabregas returns to Chelsea´s XI|
|Ronaldo is no genius like Messi - Capello|
|Everything is wonderful with Boateng - Rummenigge|
|Wenger to drop Jenkinson to protect him from social media taunts|
|Sakho not part of Liverpool´s first-team plans|
|Hughes offers Hitzfeld Stoke invite after Shaqiri comments|
|Roberto Carlos: Ronaldo is the best in the world, still!|
|Robben hopeful of finalising Bayern future|
|Sarri talks up Balotelli to Napoli|
|Everton need time and changes, says Koeman|
|Ancelotti lauds Muller after Bayern win|
|Sterling: I have more freedom under Guardiola|
|Mourinho: Maybe no Premier League title for United this season|
|Bayern laid down a marker - Rummenigge|
|Conte ´maybe the best in the world´ - Guardiola|
|Pioli laments Inter´s ´step backwards´|
|Ronaldo and Mourinho ´fully compliant´ with tax obligations, insists Gestifute|
|Napoli 3 Inter 0: Pioli dealt emphatic first Serie A defeat|
|Mainz 1 Bayern Munich 3: Lewandowski double inspires champions|
|´I have found my luck at Leipzig´ - Hasenhuttl dismisses Arsenal talk|
|Messi better to watch than Ronaldo, says Saviola|
|´I don´t care about age´ - Klopp committed to promoting youngsters|
|Koeman: Ibrahimovic was fantastic at 19|
|Pulis not letting court decision tarnish Palace memories|
|Carroll to make West Ham return against Arsenal|
|Real Madrid must win LaLiga and end Barca dominance - Roberto Carlos|
|Barcelona v Real Madrid: Zidane´s men eye LaLiga supremacy|
|Costa discipline issues in the past - Conte|
|A-League review: Melbourne Victory held by Perth Glory|
|I deserve criticism if Dortmund´s players do - Tuchel|
|Emery wants Cavani to dethrone Ibrahimovic|
|Martial is happy again, says Mourinho|
|Guardiola wary of Costa and Pedro|
|Messi, Ronaldo and Griezmann to battle it out for FIFA award|
|Conte reveals admiration for Guardiola philosophy|
|Mourinho: Schweinsteiger can stay at Man Utd|
|Conte: It is a pity Chelsea sold De Bruyne|
|Carrasco now competing with Griezmann and Gameiro - Simeone|
|Luis Enrique: Clasico not decisive in title race|
|Barcelona have no weaknesses - Zidane|
|Zidane: Ronaldo´s hunger for success key for Real Madrid|
|Barcelona midfielder Iniesta back for Clasico|
|Higuain does not need Dybala to score - Allegri|
|Summerbee: Chelsea blew it with De Bruyne|
|Ranieri, Zidane and Santos up for FIFA coach award|
|Chelsea paid me £50,000 to prevent child abuse revelations - Johnson|
|Vertonghen signs new Tottenham deal|
|Klopp hopeful on Lallana and Firmino|
|Ozil: Arsenal can win Champions League with a bit of luck|
|Sturridge exit a non-story, says Klopp|
|Debuchy out for up to six weeks|
|Pardew ready to turn around slumping Palace|
|Arsenal will not sign Cazorla replacement - Wenger|
|Courtois not getting carried away over Chelsea form|
|CAS to rule on Blatter case on Monday|
|Ozil refuses to rule out Real Madrid return|
|Sterling: I am keeping away from certain stuff I was doing last year|
|Leverkusen´s Volland out until 2017|
|Aloisi rules out Roar swoop for Keane|
|Pele reflects on ´sad moment´ of Chapecoense tragedy|
|Southgate urges downtime responsibility from England|
|Ranieri: Leicester signings not to blame for poor form|
|Sky is the limit for ´special´ Donnarumma, says Hart|