Sheffield United returned to last season's giant-killing form as they knocked West Ham out of the League Cup on penalties at Upton Park.
Enner Valencia made his first start for West Ham, but the World Cup star missed the crucial penalty in the shootout, allowing Michael Doyle to seal a 5-4 win following a 1-1 draw after 120 minutes.
Nigel Clough led his League One side to wins over two Premier League teams on their run to the FA Cup semi-finals last term and they showed their giant-killing instincts again on Tuesday to doggedly take the game the distance.
Valencia started brightly, but it was striker partner Diafra Sakho who opened the scoring with his opening goal for the club after a spell of sustained West Ham pressure in the first half.
Sam Allardyce made nine changes to his side from their weekend win over Crystal Palace and a lack of cohesion was perhaps to blame as the visitors roared out for the second half and hit back as Winston Reid scored an own-goal.
The Yorkshire club showed tremendous resolve to repel everything that West Ham threw at them, and grabbed a hard-fought spot in the third round.
In front of a packed Upton Park crowd, Valencia looked a threat from the off through the right channel, stinging Mark Howard's palms from 25 yards 20 minutes in before the former Arsenal trainee stood tall to deny the Ecuador striker in a one-on-one.
The visitors were again indebted to Howard when he tipped Ravel Morrison's free-kick around the post and then impressively kept out teenage debutant Reece Burke's acrobatic effort from the resulting corner.
However, Howard was beaten five minutes before the interval as neat play between Morrison and Burke led to the latter swinging a cross in for Sakho, who glanced a header over the goalkeeper and into the net.
Allardyce's side looked slack immediately after the break, however, and Sheffield United took advantage as Bob Harris zipped up the left flank and his cross was flicked on by Mark McNulty, giving a hapless Reid no chance to react, shinning into his own net.
The West Ham boss reacted by throwing Stewart Downing on for goalscorer Sakho and the winger had an instant impact on the left, crossing for Reid and Valencia, who were unable to convert.
Mauro Zarate was introduced as the hosts grew desperate, the Argentine attacker bringing a scrambled save out of Howard after the keeper had kept out Downing's powerful effort from range, but it was not enough and the game drifted into extra time.
The away side tenaciously defended their goal in the extra periods, blocking a number of shots from West Ham.
Howard again made a stunning save to deny Mark Noble's curler and the hosts failed to craft a telling chance in the final 10 minutes, taking the game to penalties.
After eight perfect spot-kicks, Valencia stepped up for West Ham's fifth, only for Howard to save to his right.
And Doyle took full advantage, sending Jussi Jaaskelainen the wrong way to take Sheffield United to the third round for the first time since 2008.
|Strootman: Totti could play for another five years|
|Saul: United target Griezmann important but no one is above Atletico|
|Strootman always knew he would extend Roma contract|
|Iniesta refuses to commit to Barcelona|
|Higuain: I have affection for Real Madrid rival Ramos|
|AFC Champions League Review: Al Ain hit six against Esteghlal as Al-Ahli defeat Al-Ahli|
|Eintracht Braunschweig 0 Wolfsburg 1 (0-2 agg): Vieirinha seals Bundesliga survival|
|Buffon deserves Ballon d´Or for current form, not past achievements - Chiellini|
|I hope he calls it a day - Adams urges Wenger not to spoil Arsenal reign|
|Allegri not worried by Juve final record|
|Another promotion campaign daunting for defeated Stam|
|The pundits wrote us off - Wagner hails Huddersfield´s fairytale promotion to Premier League|
|The night Valverde embarrassed Barcelona|
|Managing egos, sorting the defence and playing the Barca way - Valverde´s Camp Nou challenges|
|Valverde named new Barcelona boss|
|Huddersfield Town 0 Reading 0 (aet, 4-3 pens): Ward the hero as Wagner´s men go up|
|Chiellini: Juve better than 2015 Champions League final loss|
|Strootman signs new five-year Roma deal|
|Pellegrino leaves Alaves after Copa final defeat|
|Bye for now - Hart departs Torino after loan spell|
|BREAKING NEWS: Ter Stegen agrees Barcelona renewal until 2022|
|Bartra feared for his career after Dortmund bus attack|
|Dortmund confirm knee ligament damage for Reus|
|Calm down - Mendy cools talk of City move with Paris video|
|AC Milan losing patience over Donnarumma|
|Terry eyes Wembley return as a manager|
|Coman pondered Bayern exit|
|Four fans die after stampede ahead of Honduran final|
|Mijatovic magic, Zidane heartache - Real Madrid and Juventus´ 1998 Champions League final|
|Moses is not a cheat - Conte|
|MLS Review: Atlanta too good for New York City, Dallas draw|
|Totti could´ve played for any big club – Ramos hails Roma great|
|Wenger: FA Cup win my presentation for new deal|
|I´m crazy about returning to Spain – Nolito eyes City exit|
|Roma defender Emerson suffers anterior cruciate ligament injury|
|Zenit sack Lucescu after missing out on Champions League|
|This was probably my last game for Benfica - Ederson hints at Man City move|
|Empoli relegated as Crotone beat Lazio to secure Serie A survival|
|Lorient 0 Troyes 0 (1-2 agg): Goalless draw sees visitors promoted to Ligue 1|
|Dzeko´s 29 goals claim Serie A Capocannoniere|
|Inter 5 Udinese 2: Perisic stars in crushing victory|
|Ausilio confirms Manchester United interest in Perisic|
|Totti: I´m not ready to say it´s over|
|Totti is not normal - De Rossi emotional after Roma icon´s farewell|
|Twenty-five seasons, 307 goals, one incredible legacy – the numbers behind Totti´s remarkable career|
|Sampdoria 2 Napoli 4: Comprehensive win not enough to snatch second place|
|Roma 3 Genoa 2: Perotti seals Champions League berth in dream farewell for Totti|
|Leave him alone! - Montella shrugs off Donnarumma error|
|I didn´t want to leave Real Madrid - Ronaldo|
|The offside rule is crazy - Cahill hits out at Sanchez FA Cup goal|
|I think Rooney wants to leave Manchester United, says Robson|
|Cagliari 2 AC Milan 1: Pisacane late show seals fitting Stadio Sant´Elia farewell|
|Inter announce Palacio departure|
|Courtois ready to sign new Chelsea contract|
|Everyone wrote me off - Critics inspired Mertesacker before Arsenal triumph|
|Emery never feared the sack at PSG|
|Barcelona future not in my hands – Paco Alcacer|
|Varane wants to see Mbappe alongside history-maker Ronaldo|
|Iniesta: I needed Busquets´ help to lift the Copa del Rey trophy!|
|Man United capable of anything - Lingard eyes glory next season|
|Freiburg´s Grifo signs Borussia Monchengladbach deal|
|Verratti expects to be at PSG next season amid Barcelona rumours|
|Coquelin: FA Cup win was for Wenger and we want him to stay|
|Ibrahimovic wanted by ´many clubs´, but he´ll stay in Europe - Raiola|
|Matuidi unsure about PSG future amid Man United links|
|Al-Khelaifi certain Emery will stay at PSG|
|MLS Review: Galaxy win Clasico, Sporting KC beaten|
|He will be at the Wanda Metropolitano – Atletico hint at Griezmann stay|
|Mexico 1 Croatia 2: Hernandez breaks record in surprise loss|
|Mexico 1 Croatia 2: Hernandez breaks record in surprise loss|
|Luis Enrique hails ´extraterrestrial´ Messi|
|Every player wants to play more – Fabregas cagey on Chelsea future after final omission|
|Tuchel hopes to continue as Borussia Dortmund boss|
|Kompany adamant Stones ´has everything´|
|People talk too much about China - Costa would only leave Chelsea for Atletico|
|Conte clear-headed for close season after Chelsea´s Wembley woe|