Alexis Sanchez's brace proved the difference as an assured Chile handed England a 2-0 defeat, their first for a year at Wembley.
The Barcelona forward scored three times in his country's last two FIFA World Cup qualification games as they plotted a successful route to the finals in Brazil, and he stole in to net a seventh-minute header ahead of Leighton Baines, who was given the nod ahead of Ashley Cole at left-back for England.
Chile's slick interplay regularly caused problem's for England's defence, but visiting goalkeeper Claudio Bravo was forced into sharp stops from Frank Lampard and Jack Wilshere in an enjoyably open first-half.
The usual flurry of substitutions after the break disturbed the game's flow as England's failure to locate the final pass undermined their efforts and, in injury time, Gary Cahill carelessly gave away possession and Sanchez produced a superb chipped finish to put gloss on the victory.
In the first of three friendlies before selecting his final 23-man squad for the 2014 FIFA World Cup finals in Brazil, England manager Roy Hodgson handed debuts to Celtic goalkeeper Fraser Forster and in-form Southampton duo Adam Lallana and Jay Rodriguez.
Chile were without key man Arturo Vidal, who suffered a thigh strain in Juventus's 3-0 weekend win over Napoli.
England started brightly but after Phil Jones and James Milner tested an uncertain-looking Bravo, opposite number Forster’s first act was to pick the ball out of his net.
Jones' block thwarted Charles Aranguiz, only for Sanchez to dive across Baines and head home when Jean Beausejour sent the ball back into England's box from the left.
Forster beat away Beausejour’s 14th-minute effort as a busy night shaped up for both goalkeepers - Bravo athletically turning Lampard’s deflected free-kick over the crossbar before fisting Wilshere’s rasping left-footer away.
But England remained defensively unsettled by Chile’s pace and directness and, after Gary Medel wasted a free header, Beausejour offered an ill-fitting conclusion to a wonderful 31st-minute counter- by failing to get a shot off as Forster forced him wide.
Just as Chile’s passing game was starting to dominate, England produced their best move of the match in the 44th minute – Wilshere and Wayne Rooney combining to feed Lallana, whose shot was deflected past the far post.
Despite a flurry of corners early in the second period, England were chasing shadows once more as Chile weaved through their defensive efforts and Eugenio Mena's cross was fumbled by Forster.
The first contribution of substitutes Chris Smalling and Gonzalo Jara was to receive bookings for an altercation at an England corner with an hour played after Baines’ free-kick dropped wide via the wall.
By that time, regular substitutions had taken their toll on the contest but Sanchez was still on hand to provide a delightful finale.
He stole in deep into injury time as the visitors claimed an upset win.
|Coach: R. Hodgson|
for J. Rodriguez 57'
for P. Jones 57'
for J. Milner 66'
for F. Lampard 71'
for J. Wilshere 71'
for A. Lallana 77'
|Top four the priority - Van Persie|
|Liga MX Preview: Queretaro braced for Atlas challenge|
|Copa Sudamericana Preview: Sao Paulo out to arrest slump|
|MLS Preview: DC United ready to grind, Revolution host Crew|
|Argentine Primera Division Review: Newell´s unbeaten run ends|
|Mignolet shrugs Valdes, Liverpool link|
|Neville blames transfers for Newcastle form|
|Mathieu applauds Messi, Neymar partnership|
|Mignolet must improve - Carragher|
|Cole hails Lampard|
|Villa may miss opener in Australia|
|Hughes thrilled with ´deserved´ home win|
|Pardew fears for future|
|Serie A Review: Djordjevic treble fires Lazio to Palermo win|
|Pardew facing ´serious conversations´ with Ashley|
|Pacos de Ferreira 2 Belenenses 0: Hosts off the mark on home turf|
|Stoke City 1 Newcastle United 0: Crouch deepens gloom for visitors|
|Garcia embracing underdogs tag|
|Turkish Super Lig Review: Gekas double sinks Fenerbahce|
|Bayer Leverkusen v Benfica: Schmidt´s men seek goalscoring touch|
|Costa to start against Sporting|
|Russian Premier League Review: CSKA edge Ural thriller to close gap on Zenit|
|Ludogorets v Real Madrid: Holders out to avoid slip-up in Sofia|
|Malmo v Olympiacos: Roberto insists no hangover for visitors|
|Championship Preview: McKinlay in at Watford, Norwich host unbeaten Charlton|
|Luis Enrique expecting stern PSG test|
|Atletico Madrid v Juventus: Opening defeat puts pressure on hosts|
|Bruce staying positive despite winless run|
|Police investigating Van Dijk racism claims|
|Hazard dreaming of Champions League glory|
|Santos goes to Goa|
|Double delight for Al-Garni|
|Basel v Liverpool: Rodgers hopeful on Sturridge return|
|Arsenal v Galatasaray: Wenger facing selection headache|
|Blanc calling on others to cover for Ibrahimovic absence|
|Zenit v Monaco: Jardim sticking with style|
|Ibrahimovic out of Barca clash|
|Lucescu happy to host Porto in Lviv|
|Hart looking to bounce back against Roma|
|McKinlay replaces Garcia at Watford|
|Anderlecht v Borussia Dortmund: Hasi expecting tough test|
|Sunderland not panicking, says Jones|
|Pelle hopes for Italy call|
|Slutsky well aware of Bayern strength|
|Guardiola entering unchartered territory|
|Arsenal have a point to prove against Chelsea - Oxlade-Chamberlain|
|Irvine hails Lescott impact|
|Carlos backs Ancelotti to defend crown|
|Montoya replaces injured Douglas|
|Pearce wants permanent Hunt deal|
|Nolan targets top 10|
|Mangala reaction pleases Kompany|
|Dyche keen to emulate West Brom example|
|Irvine happy to see Hawthorns rocking again|
|San Siro ´isn´t enough anymore´ for Milan|
|Redknapp calls for temporary subs|
|Western Sydney Wanderers v Seoul: A-League side look to continue dream run|
|Hazard rules out PSG switch|
|MLS Review: Keane scores twice in Galaxy romp|
|Costa Rican Primera Division Review: Five-star Alajuelense extend streak|
|Colombian Primera A Review: Medellin held, Santa Fe go top|
|Liga del Futbol Profesional Boliviano Review: Wilstermann remain top|
|Napoli rewarded for team effort - Benitez|
|Liga MX Review: Layun scores four, Monterrey leapfrog Atlas|
|Paraguayan Division Profesional Review: 15-year-old Diaz is Cerro´s hero|
|Uruguayan Primera Division Review: Racing leave it late, Recoba scores from a corner|
|Brazilian Serie A Review: Gremio´s resurgence continues|
|Venezuelan Primera Division Review: Leaders held, Tucanes win again|
|Referee got it right - Rooney|
|Peruvian Primera Division Review: Melgar stay perfect|
|Bielsa: Marseille always in control|
|Newcastle will offer Tiote new deal - Pardew|
|Shakhtar Donetsk v Porto: Lucescu looks to maintain impressive home record|
|Ligue 1 Review: Marseille, Bordeaux continue fine starts|
|Serie A review: Inter stunned, Sampdoria derby delight|
|APOEL v Ajax: De Boer hoping to end poor away form|
|Schalke v Maribor: Draxler set for return for confident hosts|
|Al Ahly 2 Coton Sport 1 (agg 3-1): Hosts secure historic final berth|
|Sporting Lisbon v Chelsea: Hosts protecting fearsome home record|
|CSKA Moscow v Bayern Munich: Robben calls for psychological focus|
|Primeira Liga Review: Gil Vicente´s misery continues|
|Bundesliga Review: Late Piazon strike stuns Hamburg, Augsburg edge out Hertha|
|Dyche wants Burnley to bounce straight back|
|Hard work paying off for West Brom - Irvine|
|Paris Saint-Germain v Barcelona: Blanc hopeful of Ibrahimovic return|
|Eredivisie Review: PSV lose at Heerenveen, Twente win|
|TP Mazembe 3 ES Setif 2 (agg 4-4): Away goals secure final berth for Algerians|
|West Brom 4 Burnley 0: Berahino shines in routine win|
|Mazzarri accepts blame for Cagliari humbling|
|Inzaghi frustrated with Milan draw|
|Manchester City v Roma: Zabaleta ready for crucial clash|
|CSL Review: Evergrande take dramatic Guangzhou derby|
|Cesena 1 Milan 1: Rami rescues point for Inzaghi´s men|
|Inter 1 Cagliari 4: Ekdal hat-trick inspires sensational away win|
|Reading 3 Wolves 3: Late Murray leveller earns draw|
|BATE v Athletic Bilbao: La Liga side look to kick-start season|
|Luiz needs time - Blanc|
|Every day is difficult - Guardiola|
|Martinez hails Hibbert and Browning|
|Lallana getting fitter - Rodgers|
|My best is yet to come - Rooney|
|K.League Review: Pohang snatch draw against leaders, Busan I´Park claim much-needed win|
|Chadli revels in derby goal|
|Al Ain v Al Hilal: Uphill battle for Dalic´s men|
|Koeman praises Mane and Bertrand|
|Costa needs 15 days to recover - Mourinho|
|Serie A not a two-horse race - Tevez|
|MLS Review: Seattle go top, Toronto fight back to win|
|Atletico were simply better - Emery|
|Gerrard: I´m not finished yet|
|Persipura v Al Qadsia: Visitors set to reach final|
|Kitchee v Erbil: Belencoso key for hosts|
|Ecuadorian Primera A Review: Barcelona continue good form|
|Sakho sorry for pre-game departure|
|Berahino ´lost´ after Clarke exit|
|La Liga Review: Big guns win|
|Home fans key to Atletico success - Simeone|
|Primeira Liga Review: Benfica win thriller, Braga beat Rio Ave|