Jack Colback's 95th-minute equaliser piled more misery on Cardiff City as Sunderland came from behind to claim a 2-2 draw on Saturday.
The Welsh side looked to be in complete control in their first game following the sacking of boss Malky Mackay by controversial club owner Vincent Tan, after Jordon Mutch had opened the scoring with a deflected strike after just six minutes.
Three points appeared to be a formality when former Sunderland man Fraizer Campbell struck in the early stages of the second half.
But Sunderland refused to lie down, and they gave themselves hope when Steven Fletcher pulled a goal back with seven minutes left to set up a frantic finish.
There was still time for even more late drama and the comeback was completed with the last meaningful kick of the game when Colback found the net with a deflected effort to spark jubilant scenes in the away end and leave the Premier League's bottom side just two points adrift of safety.
There was worrying news for Sunderland, though, after reports that Fabio Borini had been taken to hospital after collapsing at half-time.
Gary Medel was restored to the Cardiff midfield as one of three changes made by interim coaches David Kerslake and Joe McBride, while Sunderland boss Poyet - without Adam Johnson through illness - selected Jozy Altidore to lead the line in place of Fletcher.
Cardiff made a bright start and they were denied a penalty in the first minute as referee Chris Foy ruled that Mutch had dived after a challenge with Valentin Roberge.
The 22-year-old was instead booked for simulation, and Mutch was again involved in the game's first real chance shortly afterwards, the midfielder meeting Craig Noone's cross with a powerful header that flew over the crossbar.
He was finally rewarded for his initiative after six minutes when he capitalised on ponderous defending from the visitors to burst forward and fire a shot that deflected off Modibo Diakite and into the bottom corner.
Sunderland struggled to gain a foothold in the contest and owed much to their goalkeeper, Vito Mannone, who produced an excellent fingertip save to keep out Kim Bo-Kyung's fierce long-range drive.
The chances continued to flow for the hosts as Steven Caulker, Peter Whittingham and Campbell all went close to adding to their lead.
However, it was Sunderland who perhaps should have scored the game's second goal just after the half-hour mark when Altidore somehow shot wide with the goal at his mercy after David Marshall had failed to deal with an effort from Ki Sung-Yueng.
Sunderland brought Fletcher on in place of Borini at the break - the Liverpool loanee apparently suffering an illness - and their task was made even harder 12 minutes into the second period when Campbell converted Mutch's pull back.
Lee Cattermole went close to finding a reply soon after but then Fletcher frayed the home nerves as he turned home an Emanuele Giaccherini cross seven minutes from time.
That set up a late Sunderland onslaught, with Fletcher and Roberge both going close, but it was Colback who proved to be the hero in the fifth minute of injury time as his effort from the edge of the box took a wicked deflection past a despairing Marshall.
|We have to stay awake all the time - Coutinho frustrated after Sevilla collapse|
|Everton 1 Atalanta 5: Cristante and Cornelius knock more shine off Premier League strugglers|
|AC Milan 5 Austria Wien 1: Andre Silva sends Montella´s men through to the last 32|
|Wasteful Arsenal leave Wenger frustrated|
|McInnes to remain at Aberdeen despite links to Rangers, West Brom|
|Robinho given prison sentence in Italy for 2013 sexual assault|
|Cologne 1 Arsenal 0: Gunners secure top spot despite defeat|
|Silva not giving ´one more word´ on Everton speculation|
|Everton sign Bramley Moore Dock lease|
|UEFA investigating Bayern after fans throw fake money in protest over Champions League prices|
|Robben out of Gladbach clash with ´minor´ calf strain|
|Pochettino pleased to see Rose emotion|
|Mourinho factor makes Man Utd a title threat, says Lampard|
|Chelsea´s best chance of success is Champions League, claims Lampard|
|Robben: It could be over for me after this season|
|Newcastle Jets 4 Melbourne Victory 1: Nabbout at the double|
|Happy Sanchez could win the Premier League for Arsenal, Lauren claims|
|Angered Neymar storms away from Real Madrid questions|
|Bayern played their worst ´for a long time´ - Boateng|
|Neymar form no surprise for Alves|
|Federer congratulates Basel after Man Utd scalp|
|Gremio 1 Lanus 0: Cicero gives Brazilians advantage in Libertadores final|
|Hazard: I admire Madrid, but I´m happy at Chelsea|
|Neuer or De Gea? Digne says Ter Stegen is world´s best keeper|
|Allegri satisfied with draw against ´extraordinary´ Barcelona|
|Nainggolan reaffirms Roma commitment after Simeone praise|
|Simeone hails Griezmann´s ´extraordinary´ volley|
|Emery hails Neymar after stunning Celtic win|
|Championship Review: Wolves thrash 10-man Leeds, Middlesbrough cruise|
|Goncharenko delighted for clean sheet star Akinfeev|
|I hope Barcelona rest Messi – Jesus|
|Thiago suffered a serious injury, says Heynckes|
|Valverde explains decision to bench Messi|
|Iniesta hails ´splendid´ Ter Stegen as Barcelona seal last-16 spot|
|Griezmann shrugs off goalless streak after wonderstrike keeps Atletico´s hopes alive|
|We should have been 5-0 up – Mourinho unimpressed with wasteful United|
|Toure reveals Guardiola anger with City´s Feyenoord display|
|Paris Saint-Germain set Champions League scoring record in Celtic rout|
|Sporting CP 3 Olympiacos 1: Dost on target as hosts stay in contention|
|Bielsa suspended by struggling Lille|
|Anderlecht 1 Bayern Munich 2: Lewandowski and Tolisso give visitors win|
|Atletico Madrid 2 Roma 0: Griezmann returns to form with wondergoal|
|Basel 1 Manchester United 0: Late Lang goal leaves Mourinho´s men with work to do|
|Paris Saint-Germain 7 Celtic 1: Cavani and Neymar score braces in sparkling win|
|Juventus 0 Barcelona 0: Messi benched but Valverde´s men in last 16|
|Conte pleased to take pressure off Atletico clash|
|Success in Europe will help Milan´s league form, Montella claims|
|Bauza sacked by Saudi Arabia|
|Willian: For me, it was a penalty|
|Akinfeev keeps first Champions League clean sheet since November 2006|
|Messi rested by Barcelona side for Juventus clash|
|CSKA Moscow 2 Benfica 0: Goncharenko´s men boost progression hopes|
|Qarabag 0 Chelsea 4: Hazard, Willian lead Blues into last 16|
|If he´s fit, he will go – Wenger backs Welbeck for World Cup call|
|Niasse banned over diving charge after FA rejects Everton appeal|
|Real Madrid´s Carvajal faces UEFA investigation over APOEL booking|
|Everton fined €30,000 over fan trouble against Lyon|
|No change in Everton manager hunt, says Unsworth|
|Chiellini to miss Barcelona match with thigh injury|
|Former Everton and Nigeria striker Yakubu retires|
|Liverpool looking into claims of Seville police assault against fans|
|Toure hails Foden as the ´future´ of Manchester City|
|Record Ronaldo nomination as Real Madrid dominate UEFA Team of the Year candidates|
|Heynckes stay is ´best solution´ for Bayern, says Robben|
|Courtois parks Chelsea contract talks|
|Wigan´s two-goal Colclough makes mad dash to witness birth of son...in full kit!|
|Sevilla boss Berizzo diagnosed with prostate cancer|
|Manchester United move still a possibility for Atletico star Griezmann|
|Carragher slams Liverpool for playing ´like children´ in Sevilla collapse|
|Replacing you might not be a great idea! – Buffon grateful for Rakitic tribute|
|Messi closes on century but Pogba must do more – Champions League in Opta numbers|
|Skoko wants Australian coach as Arnold emerges as Postecoglou replacement|
|Everton yet to make contact with Van Gaal|
|MLS Review: Sounders a step closer to final, Crew and Toronto in stalemate|
|Ben Yedder trolls Liverpool after dramatic Sevilla comeback|
|´World class´ Insigne can´t be rested – Sarri|
|I say one thing and you write something else - Angry Ronaldo brushes off media|
|Griezmann needs support of Atletico and fans – Simeone|
|Monaco paid for mistakes in Champions League exit - Jardim|
|We had to rely on personal pride - Berizzo praises Sevilla´s stunning comeback|
|Championship Review: Coleman loses first Sunderland game, Fulham win nine-goal thriller|
|City fans get first sight of local star they crave in Phil Foden|
|Gunes wants more after historic Besiktas Champions League qualification|
|Allegri plays down Dybala-Messi comparisons|
|Extra rest helped Rose shine in Dortmund – Pochettino|