Jack Colback's 95th-minute equaliser piled more misery on Cardiff City as Sunderland came from behind to claim a 2-2 draw on Saturday.
The Welsh side looked to be in complete control in their first game following the sacking of boss Malky Mackay by controversial club owner Vincent Tan, after Jordon Mutch had opened the scoring with a deflected strike after just six minutes.
Three points appeared to be a formality when former Sunderland man Fraizer Campbell struck in the early stages of the second half.
But Sunderland refused to lie down, and they gave themselves hope when Steven Fletcher pulled a goal back with seven minutes left to set up a frantic finish.
There was still time for even more late drama and the comeback was completed with the last meaningful kick of the game when Colback found the net with a deflected effort to spark jubilant scenes in the away end and leave the Premier League's bottom side just two points adrift of safety.
There was worrying news for Sunderland, though, after reports that Fabio Borini had been taken to hospital after collapsing at half-time.
Gary Medel was restored to the Cardiff midfield as one of three changes made by interim coaches David Kerslake and Joe McBride, while Sunderland boss Poyet - without Adam Johnson through illness - selected Jozy Altidore to lead the line in place of Fletcher.
Cardiff made a bright start and they were denied a penalty in the first minute as referee Chris Foy ruled that Mutch had dived after a challenge with Valentin Roberge.
The 22-year-old was instead booked for simulation, and Mutch was again involved in the game's first real chance shortly afterwards, the midfielder meeting Craig Noone's cross with a powerful header that flew over the crossbar.
He was finally rewarded for his initiative after six minutes when he capitalised on ponderous defending from the visitors to burst forward and fire a shot that deflected off Modibo Diakite and into the bottom corner.
Sunderland struggled to gain a foothold in the contest and owed much to their goalkeeper, Vito Mannone, who produced an excellent fingertip save to keep out Kim Bo-Kyung's fierce long-range drive.
The chances continued to flow for the hosts as Steven Caulker, Peter Whittingham and Campbell all went close to adding to their lead.
However, it was Sunderland who perhaps should have scored the game's second goal just after the half-hour mark when Altidore somehow shot wide with the goal at his mercy after David Marshall had failed to deal with an effort from Ki Sung-Yueng.
Sunderland brought Fletcher on in place of Borini at the break - the Liverpool loanee apparently suffering an illness - and their task was made even harder 12 minutes into the second period when Campbell converted Mutch's pull back.
Lee Cattermole went close to finding a reply soon after but then Fletcher frayed the home nerves as he turned home an Emanuele Giaccherini cross seven minutes from time.
That set up a late Sunderland onslaught, with Fletcher and Roberge both going close, but it was Colback who proved to be the hero in the fifth minute of injury time as his effort from the edge of the box took a wicked deflection past a despairing Marshall.
|European clubs benefit from UEFA agreement|
|Vassell: Sky is the limit for Kane|
|Manchester United move would be an ´honour´ for Coentrao|
|Insigne out to bolster Napoli season after lay-off|
|Rooney warns Kane over ´clever´ Italy defenders|
|Rangers results reveal £500,000 Newcastle clause|
|Southampton announce £33.4m profit|
|´I am a very flexible man´ - Van Gaal|
|A-League Preview: Top spot up for grabs|
|Portugal - Cape Verde Preview: Andre and Oliveira eager for international bows|
|Puerto Rico 0 Canada 3: Floro´s men rout hosts|
|Xavi denies Al Sadd link|
|Fernando´s life ban upheld by CAS|
|Argentina - Ecuador Preview: Messi remains doubtful for friendly|
|Falcao equals Colombia´s all-time scoring record|
|Macedonia trip good learning curve - Postecoglou|
|Macedonia 0 Australia 0: Stalemate in Skopje|
|Del Bosque not out for Netherlands revenge|
|Burton Albion 1 Stevenage 1: Both teams score at wrong end in draw|
|Pekerman: I have no say on Falcao´s Manchester United future|
|Buffon has studied England new boy Kane|
|Conte urges patience from Italy fans|
|Johnson tasked with keeping Cheltenham up|
|Rooney not keen on Serie A switch|
|Kane to make first England start|
|Colombia 3 Kuwait 1: Spot-on Falcao equals Iguaran record|
|Goal-shy Barkley eyes striker´s role|
|UEFA opens disciplinary proceedings against Montenegro and Russia|
|Draxler and Choupo-Moting back in training|
|Ghana v Mali: Last chance to impress before Giresse return|
|Wilson: Gibraltar getting stronger|
|Mata confident of Spain future|
|Armenia coach Challandes resigns|
|Hiddink rubbishes talk of Dutch negativity|
|Portugal v Cape Verde: Santos set to rotate|
|Loren hails Moyes for Sociedad surge|
|Cruyff brands Netherlands ´a disgrace´|
|Kick It Out backs Barnes over race comments|
|Argentina v Ecuador: Messi remains doubtful for friendly|
|Coates backs Hughes ambition at Stoke|
|Atletico able to call on Saul again|
|Italy v England Preview: Kane set to start after dream debut|
|Zidane would accept Real job|
|Hernandez frustrated by lack of Real opportunities|
|Spartak donate money to 102-year-old fan after robbery|
|Clasie pulls out of Netherlands squad|
|Italy´s Bertolacci out of England friendly|
|Newcastle post record profit as Ashley debt stays the same|
|Al Sadd: We want Xavi to bring tiki-taka|
|Lacazette expected frosty Saint-Etienne reception|
|Barnes: I can´t get back into management because I´m black|
|Rooney praises England aggression|
|Southgate tips Kane for return to U21s|
|Mexico v Paraguay: Goals in order for Copa America aspirants|
|Netherlands - Spain Preview: Wijnaldum rallies behind under-fire Hiddink|
|Peru v Venezuela: Sanvicente wants Venezuelan response|
|Carvalho confident of playing Juventus|
|Neymar demands protection after Medel stamp|
|MLS Review: RSL, Fire secure breakthrough wins|
|Firmino firmly on radar - Dunga|
|O´Neill delighted with second-half display|
|First-half dominance pleases Deschamps|
|Muller criticises Germany profligacy|
|Euro 2016 Qualifying Review: Portugal go top, Gibraltar make history in defeat|
|Liverpool the only English club I could play for - Suarez|
|France 2 Denmark 0: Lacazette off the mark in routine victory|
|Republic of Ireland 1 Poland 1: Long rescues vital point|
|Portugal 2 Serbia 1: Coentrao puts hosts top of Group I|
|Strachan hails ´terrific´ Gibraltar|
|Lafferty back playing with a smile on his face - O´Neill|
|Toure to reveal Ivory Coast future over coming days|
|Georgia 0 Germany 2: Reus and Muller on target for world champions|
|Northern Ireland 2 Finland 1: Lafferty inspires fourth qualifying success|
|Scotland 6 Gibraltar 1: Casciaro´s historic moment outshone by Fletcher´s hat-trick|
|France 2-0 Denmark: Lacazette and Giroud on target|
|Firmino hopeful of Copa America spot|
|Hummels considering options at Dortmund|
|Suarez goalless on Anfield return, but Balotelli nets stunner|
|Casciaro scores first competitive goal for Gibraltar|
|Fleetwood Town 1 Preston North End 1: Ball stunner claims share of derby spoils|
|Italy v England: Judge me on results, says Conte|
|Colombia v Kuwait: Falcao seeking another strong showing|
|Brazil 1 Chile 0: Firmino settles scrappy affair|
|Luxembourg v Turkey: Let´s kick on, urges Terim|
|South Africa 1 Nigeria 1: Zungu strikes late to earn draw|
|Smalling wants long-term United stay|
|South Africa 1-1 Nigeria: Last-gasp Zungu goal cancels out Musa strike|
|Italy call up Santon and Abate for England friendly|
|Switzerland v United States: Klinsmann eyes learning curve|
|Netherlands v Spain: Hiddink has players´ support, says Wijnaldum|
|A-League Review: Sydney end Wellington run, Adelaide suffer injury blows in Jets win|
|Henderson eyes long-term Liverpool future|
|I have nothing to prove - Bale|
|Brazil 1-0 Chile: Firmino gives Selecao battling victory|
|South Korea v New Zealand: All Whites looking to future|
|Japan v Uzbekistan: Hosts eye another win under Halilhodzic|
|MLS Review: Kaka nets in Orlando draw|
|Mexico 1 Ecuador 0: Hernandez, Corona help Herrera´s men to victory|
|Deschamps calls for France response|
|Dunga unfazed by pressure|
|Montenegro fan turns himself in after flare incident|
|Injured Messi not ready - Martino|
|Hodgson: Rooney not close to Charlton|
|Terim proud of Turkey|
|Hiddink happy with point|
|Euro 2016 Qualifying Review: Netherlands and Italy stage late escapes|
|Debutant Eder delighted with Azzurri bow|