Jack Colback's 95th-minute equaliser piled more misery on Cardiff City as Sunderland came from behind to claim a 2-2 draw on Saturday.
The Welsh side looked to be in complete control in their first game following the sacking of boss Malky Mackay by controversial club owner Vincent Tan, after Jordon Mutch had opened the scoring with a deflected strike after just six minutes.
Three points appeared to be a formality when former Sunderland man Fraizer Campbell struck in the early stages of the second half.
But Sunderland refused to lie down, and they gave themselves hope when Steven Fletcher pulled a goal back with seven minutes left to set up a frantic finish.
There was still time for even more late drama and the comeback was completed with the last meaningful kick of the game when Colback found the net with a deflected effort to spark jubilant scenes in the away end and leave the Premier League's bottom side just two points adrift of safety.
There was worrying news for Sunderland, though, after reports that Fabio Borini had been taken to hospital after collapsing at half-time.
Gary Medel was restored to the Cardiff midfield as one of three changes made by interim coaches David Kerslake and Joe McBride, while Sunderland boss Poyet - without Adam Johnson through illness - selected Jozy Altidore to lead the line in place of Fletcher.
Cardiff made a bright start and they were denied a penalty in the first minute as referee Chris Foy ruled that Mutch had dived after a challenge with Valentin Roberge.
The 22-year-old was instead booked for simulation, and Mutch was again involved in the game's first real chance shortly afterwards, the midfielder meeting Craig Noone's cross with a powerful header that flew over the crossbar.
He was finally rewarded for his initiative after six minutes when he capitalised on ponderous defending from the visitors to burst forward and fire a shot that deflected off Modibo Diakite and into the bottom corner.
Sunderland struggled to gain a foothold in the contest and owed much to their goalkeeper, Vito Mannone, who produced an excellent fingertip save to keep out Kim Bo-Kyung's fierce long-range drive.
The chances continued to flow for the hosts as Steven Caulker, Peter Whittingham and Campbell all went close to adding to their lead.
However, it was Sunderland who perhaps should have scored the game's second goal just after the half-hour mark when Altidore somehow shot wide with the goal at his mercy after David Marshall had failed to deal with an effort from Ki Sung-Yueng.
Sunderland brought Fletcher on in place of Borini at the break - the Liverpool loanee apparently suffering an illness - and their task was made even harder 12 minutes into the second period when Campbell converted Mutch's pull back.
Lee Cattermole went close to finding a reply soon after but then Fletcher frayed the home nerves as he turned home an Emanuele Giaccherini cross seven minutes from time.
That set up a late Sunderland onslaught, with Fletcher and Roberge both going close, but it was Colback who proved to be the hero in the fifth minute of injury time as his effort from the edge of the box took a wicked deflection past a despairing Marshall.
|Euro 2016 Qualifying: As it finished|
|Bazdarevic lauds Bosnia-Herzegovina courage|
|Hogmo upset as Norway miss out on automatic qualification|
|Srna: We are heroes after Euro 2016 qualification|
|Ecuador 2 Bolivia 0: Late double settles sodden encounter|
|Blind backed to stay on by KNVB director|
|Coleman urges Wales to ´do something special´ at Euro 2016|
|Blind wants to remain Netherlands coach after Euro 2016 qualifying heartbreak|
|Kompany proud to lead Belgium to the top of the world|
|Euro 2016 Qualifying Review: Turkey seal dramatic qualification as Croatia edge through to France|
|Conte praises Italy´s grit and intensity|
|Sneijder: Blind not to blame|
|CAF World Cup Qualifying Review: Niger thump Somalia|
|Motherwell bring back McGhee as manager|
|Wales 2 Andorra 0: Ramsey and Bale see off stubborn minnows in Cardiff|
|Belgium 3 Israel 1: Mertens, De Bruyne and Hazard seal top spot|
|Italy 2 Norway 1: Comeback denies Hogmo´s men automatic qualification|
|Netherlands 2 Czech Republic 3: Dutch miss out on play-off spot|
|AFC World Cup Qualifying Review: Jordan extend lead over Australia|
|Ex-UEFA chief Johansson denies knowledge of Blatter-Platini payment|
|Injured Aguero returns to Manchester|
|Blanc casts doubt on Ibrahimovic´s PSG future|
|Alexandre Pato will cost €25m - Corinthians executive|
|Allardyce opens to door to possible Nolan swoop|
|Mertesacker: Chambers destined to become one of the best|
|Evra still upset over Manchester United exit|
|Cardona reminds me of James - Pekerman|
|Monchengladbach hit by Xhaka, Schulz injuries|
|Bebe looking to win big move with Rayo form|
|McClaren laments Newcastle´s Krul blow|
|Suarez: Barcelona lack last season´s punch|
|Iran 1 Japan 1: Muto strike cancels out Torabi opener|
|Baptistao eyes Europa League success with Villarreal|
|Ronaldo: Brazil will face more difficulties|
|Tottenham have out-run everyone, Kane warns Liverpool|
|Welbeck certain Rooney´s goal drought will end|
|Payet slams ´unjust´ France snub|
|Bayern confirm Coman injury not serious|
|Fabregas: Spain want third consecutive European title|
|South Korea 3 Jamaica 0: Ki on target in confident victory|
|´Exceptional´ Ronaldo can win another Golden Shoe - Perez|
|Cristiano Ronaldo: I now want fifth Golden Shoe|
|Allardyce demands defensive improvement at Sunderland|
|Darmian: Joining Manchester United an easy decision|
|Wenger criticism is unfair - Welbeck|
|Hulk urges Brazil to win back fans|
|Vidal puts his career at risk for Chile, says Medel|
|Of course I want new Barcelona deal - Neymar|
|Di Natale backs Balotelli to lead Italy at Euro 2016|
|De Gea: I´m better than ever before|
|Butland fires warning to Hart|
|Allardyce: I love winding up ´arrogant´ Wenger|
|Arsenal´s lack of success could see them miss out on Kokorin - agent|
|Welbeck targets January return for Arsenal|
|Rakitic: We´ll win for Modric|
|Ballon d´Or is reserved for Messi - Neymar|
|Dortmund dismiss Aubameyang exit talk|
|Perisic ´decisive like Robben´ - Suker|
|Ferdinand: Fergie´s captaincy snub upset me|
|De Bruyne hungry for more goals|
|Dunga: Brazil are frustrated and lack reaction|
|Dani Alves: Time for Brazil to focus|
|I believed we would finish unbeaten - Hodgson|
|Del Bosque expects selection headache for Euro 2016|
|Ukraine 0 Spain 1: Hundred-cap Fabregas falters from the spot|
|Lithuania 0 England 3: Hodgson´s men make it a perfect 10|
|Fabregas reaches 100 Spain caps|
|Excited Conte targets top-four Euro 2016 showing|
|Spain pair Casillas and De Gea show the way for Rico|
|Liverpool not title candidates under Klopp - Barnes|
|Manchester United important to Northern Ireland success|
|Tevez cannot operate like Messi - Martino|
|Pele questions Brazil unity after qualifying loss|
|Ancelotti: Roma have the most quality in Serie A|
|Ghana v Canada: Hoilett desperate for international debut|
|Cruyff: Netherlands painful to watch|
|´No hatred´ between Bale and Ronaldo, claims Wales star´s agent|
|Mexico v Panama: Ferretti prepares for farewell|
|Wright signs new deal to end Dundee United speculation|
|Real Madrid are not making Bale demands, insists Coleman|
|Toure, Aubameyang and Salah lead CAF Player of the Year nominations|
|Neuer, De Gea the Messi and Ronaldo of goalkeeping - Ferguson|
|Sakho slams PSG over Coman treatment|
|Former FIFA Executive Committee member Makudi suspended|
|Mancini: It´s time for Inter to beat Juventus again|
|Blind talks down Depay, Van Persie row claims|
|Van Persie: Vieira inspired me to be strong mentally|
|Klopp will not ruin his reputation by raiding Dortmund - Rauball|
|Wolfsburg confirm Embolo interest|
|Sigurdsson looked up to Beckham, Lampard|
|Uruguay still a threat without Cavani and Suarez - Arias|
|PSG better than Bayern - Zidane|
|Allardyce: I deserved the England job in 2006|
|Baker: I will return to Chelsea a better player|
|I have no contact with Luis Enrique - Barca B captain Grimaldo|
|Carlo Ancelotti wants Premier League return|
|Klopp: I won´t poach Dortmund players|
|Xavi: I would have liked to play for Manchester United|
|Ronaldo´s success largely down to Benzema - Ancelotti|
|Willian ignoring his Brazil critics|
|Messi rivalry spurs on Ronaldo - Zidane|
|Klopp needs time and money - Hitzlsperger|
|United States v Costa Rica: Under-fire Klinsmann standing firm|
|Giroud satisfied with France contribution|
|Hodgson rejects easy cap claims|
|Honduras v South Africa: Mashaba´s men want consistency|
|Spain to play Belgium in November friendly|
|Lallana ´very excited´ by Klopp arrival|
|Santos: Serbia deserved to finish second|
|Iordanescu: Romania should´ve qualified earlier|
|De Biasi revels in Albania´s historic Euro 2016 berth|
|Reus misses sum up Germany´s problems - Low|
|Krul ´devastated´ after being ruled out for season|
|Lewandowski insists Poland fully deserve Euro 2016 spot|
|Deschamps urges France players to give him selection headaches|
|Hummels: Germany must seize attacking opportunities|