CARDIFF (AFP) - Furious Wales boss John Toshack slammed the performance of referee Terje Hauge following his side's 2-0 World Cup qualifying defeat by Germany here at the Millennium Stadium on Wednesday.
Toshack said the throw-in which led to captain Michael Ballack firing Germany into the lead from 30 yards should have gone to Wales and that the home side should have had a penalty after Serdar Tasci handled in the box.
Victory saw Europe zone group four leaders Germany, who scored a second through an Ashley Williams own-goal, take another step nearer next year's showpiece in South Africa.
As for Wales, last weekend's 2-0 loss at home to Finland had all but ended their hopes of reaching their first major finals since the 1958 World Cup even before they kicked-off against Germany.
"The first goal was a ridiculous decision, the throw was for Wales and the linesman had given it," said Toshack.
"Aaron Ramsey was trotting across to take it from an area of the midfield where Ballack was waiting so when the ball was passed by Ballack, Ramsey was not in any position to defend against him.
"As for the handball, it was a penalty and should have been a red card. If that had happened it may not have been so easy for Germany.
"The referee produced decisions you would not see on Llandaff (Cardiff) playing fields in park football."
Former Liverpool and Wales striker Toshack added: "Mind you, whether we would have scored a penalty is another matter, we have missed three already in this campaign, but that is not the point.
"It is tough enough playing against one of the best sides in the world without getting those decisions from the referee, we didn't deserve that."
Robert Earnshaw led Wales's attack in the absence of injured captain Craig Bellamy, who'd blasted his side after the Finland defeat.
Encouragingly for Wales, Arsenal teenage midfielder Ramsey did not look out of his depth against Germany but he was powerless to prevent Chelsea's Ballack letting fly with a dipping shot which gave keeper Wayne Hennessey no chance.
Wales though were unlucky not to have a spot-kick in the 26th minute after Gareth Bale and Joe Ledley combined down the left wing.
Tasci stumbled as he backed off the advancing Ledley inside the box and the defender's hand made contact with the ball. It seemed a penalty but Norway's Hauge dismissed Wales's appeals.
Hennessey had to save well from both Thomas Hitzlsperger and Lukas Podolski to prevent Germany doubling their lead and it wasn't until after half-time they added a second goal.
Mario Gomez managed to send in a speculative cross and Williams, sticking out a leg, diverted the ball into his own net.
This was Germany's second win in five days after they'd swept aside Liechtenstein and manager Joachim Loew said: "It was extremely important that we won these two games.
"We now have 16 points from 18 in this group with four games left. That means I am absolutely content with the situation."
Loew also brushed aside an on-field row between Ballack and Lukas Podolski in the second half which only ended after the referee intervened.
"I have not had the chance to talk to them about it, but if a captain gives out orders on the pitch it is the duty of any players to carry them out."
|Coach: J. Toshack|
for S. Ricketts 54'
for S. Vokes 63'
for L. Nyatanga 75'
|MLS Review: Kaka brace denies NYC top spot, Timbers beat Sounders|
|Mihajlovic: I won´t waste anymore breath on Maksimovic|
|Okon named Central Coast Mariners coach|
|´Special´ Rashford will get chance - Rooney|
|Injury forces Schurrle out of Germany squad|
|Burke snubs Premier League interest to join RB Leipzig|
|Guardiola: Nasri has a future at City, if he wants it|
|Klopp confident ´all will be good´ with Sturridge|
|Emery confident PSG will bounce back|
|Athletic may strengthen squad - Valverde|
|Fabregas dismisses exit rumours, committed to Conte and Chelsea|
|De Boer encouraged as Inter´s wait continues|
|Barca ´strengthened´ by Luis Enrique´s 100th win|
|Fekir to undergo knee operation|
|Monaco 3 Paris Saint-Germain 1: Ligue 1 champions suffer early loss|
|Aguero facing possible Manchester derby ban|
|Athletic Bilbao 0 Barcelona 1: Rakitic strike extends Barca´s strong start|
|West Ham´s Antonio handed first England call-up|
|Guardiola ´so optimistic´ after Man City´s perfect start|
|Inter 1 Palermo 1: Icardi gets De Boer´s men off the mark|
|Credit Guardiola for boost in form, says Sterling|
|Manchester City 3 West Ham 1: Hosts stay perfect under Guardiola|
|Cavani won´t return to Napoli - De Laurentiis|
|Pulis puts 48-hour deadline on Berahino future|
|Zaza awaits ´new adventure´ at West Ham|
|Karanka open to transfer ´surprises´ after strong Middlesbrough start|
|Dost completes Sporting move|
|Allardyce wanted N´Zonzi for England|
|World Cup could be expanded - Infantino|
|West Brom 0 Middlesbrough 0: Booed Berahino benched for dour draw|
|Gyan´s ´destiny´ in England, Sunderland return an option|
|Zidane wanted Pogba and Madrid are weaker without him - Raiola|
|Juventus end Matuidi pursuit|
|´He´s freaking amazing!´ - Balogun hails Dortmund´s Dembele|
|Thohir thrilled as Inter confirm Joao Mario signing|
|Fabinho expects Monaco stay despite Manchester United links|
|Infantino has Blatter wine cellar removed as part of FIFA reform commitment|
|West Ham seal Zaza loan|
|Joao Mario posts heartfelt thanks to Sporting after record-breaking Inter move|
|Aguero: I´m not competing with Ibrahimovic|
|Mihajlovic: Maksimovic is dead to me|
|Risdon replaces Wright for Socceroos|
|MLS Review: DC United in goal-fest, Impact stun Toronto|
|Schmeichel to undergo surgery|
|Milik revels in ´dream´ brace as he ignores Higuain shadow|
|Rossi to join Celta Vigo|
|Ayestaran: Barcelona target Alcacer unable to compete|
|Simeone: Winless Atletico must remain calm|
|Griezmann: Atletico must improve or face relegation fight|
|Sterling ´feels the love´ at City - Guardiola|
|Stones glad he did not end up at Chelsea|
|James impact earns Zidane´s praise|
|Montella bemoans AC Milan´s indiscipline|
|Leganes 0 Atletico Madrid 0: Returning Griezmann fails to inspire turgid visitors|
|Everton fan passes away after taking ill at Goodison Park|
|Napoli 4 AC Milan 2: Milik and Callejon at the double against Montella´s nine men|
|Aubameyang eyes Lewandowski duel|
|International break timely for Hull recruitment - Phelan|
|Real Madrid 2 Celta Vigo 1: Late Kroos strike saves hosts|
|Mourinho worry over Fellaini back injury|
|Allegri marvels at ´exceptional´ Khedira|
|Mourinho promises more chances for matchwinner Rashford|
|We didn´t play our best - Tuchel|
|Rashford: Setbacks part of football|
|No hiding, Arsenal want the title - Cech|
|Hull City 0 Manchester United 1: Rashford´s late show thwarts Phelan´s battlers|
|Bamford nearing Burnley loan|
|Leicester proved they are still one of the best - Guidolin|
|Pardew stands by unsettled Zaha|
|Koeman sympathises with Hughes´ frustration|
|Lazio 0 Juventus 1: Khedira nets again as Allegri´s men prevail|
|Moyes defends Pickford after late howler|
|Conte: Hazard can still improve|
|Hughes bemoans confusion over new refereeing directives|
|Howe regrets Bournemouth caution|
|Home draw leaves Puel frustrated|
|´A goalscorer never forgets´ - Ranieri thrilled as Vardy returns to form|
|Derby sign Vydra from Watford|
|Wenger flags imminent arrival of Mustafi, Perez|
|Crystal Palace 1 Bournemouth 1: Dann late show denies Cherries|
|Southampton 1 Sunderland 1: Pickford howler costs Black Cats two points|
|Chelsea 3 Burnley 0: Hazard shines in dominant win|
|Everton 1 Stoke City 0: Joy for Koeman at Given´s expense|
|Leicester City 2 Swansea City 1: Vardy and Morgan give champions first win|
|Watford 1 Arsenal 3: Sanchez inspires Gunners´ first win of the season|
|Borussia Dortmund 2 Mainz 1: Aubameyang double seals winning start for Tuchel´s men|
|Klopp defends benching Sturridge|
|Pochettino satisfied with Liverpool draw|
|Milner: Liverpool didn´t do enough after leading|
|Lahm ready to run the hard yards for Ancelotti|
|United have the fear factor back - Shaw|
|Tottenham 1 Liverpool 1: Rose denies Klopp´s men victory|
|Donnarumma called up as Ventura turns to youth|
|´Unique, exceptional work´ - Luis Enrique hails departed Bravo|
|Luis Enrique won´t rule out Munir exit|
|Portugal´s powerhouses divide to conquer once more|
|Ter Stegen, Mascherano in Barcelona squad for Athletic clash|
|Guardiola passion infectious, says Bravo|
|Palermo confident of Balotelli deal|
|Bayern are free of Guardiola´s chains, says Scholl|
|Ronaldo: I´ll be back in no time|
|Colombia name squad for Venezuela, Brazil qualifiers|
|Pellegrini becomes Hebei China Fortune coach|
|Klopp has ´no doubt´ over Henderson´s Liverpool future|
|Lallana understands questions over Liverpool displays|
|Real Salt Lake 2 Colorado Rapids 1: Movsisyan at the double|
|Wenger insists Perez and Mustafi are not panic buys|
|Ranieri confident of Vardy resurgence|
|Atletico send Jota on loan to Porto|
|Mourinho not rushing ´super´ Mkhitaryan|
|Bayern to meet Augsburg, Dortmund face Union in DFB-Pokal second round|