CARDIFF (AFP) - Furious Wales boss John Toshack slammed the performance of referee Terje Hauge following his side's 2-0 World Cup qualifying defeat by Germany here at the Millennium Stadium on Wednesday.
Toshack said the throw-in which led to captain Michael Ballack firing Germany into the lead from 30 yards should have gone to Wales and that the home side should have had a penalty after Serdar Tasci handled in the box.
Victory saw Europe zone group four leaders Germany, who scored a second through an Ashley Williams own-goal, take another step nearer next year's showpiece in South Africa.
As for Wales, last weekend's 2-0 loss at home to Finland had all but ended their hopes of reaching their first major finals since the 1958 World Cup even before they kicked-off against Germany.
"The first goal was a ridiculous decision, the throw was for Wales and the linesman had given it," said Toshack.
"Aaron Ramsey was trotting across to take it from an area of the midfield where Ballack was waiting so when the ball was passed by Ballack, Ramsey was not in any position to defend against him.
"As for the handball, it was a penalty and should have been a red card. If that had happened it may not have been so easy for Germany.
"The referee produced decisions you would not see on Llandaff (Cardiff) playing fields in park football."
Former Liverpool and Wales striker Toshack added: "Mind you, whether we would have scored a penalty is another matter, we have missed three already in this campaign, but that is not the point.
"It is tough enough playing against one of the best sides in the world without getting those decisions from the referee, we didn't deserve that."
Robert Earnshaw led Wales's attack in the absence of injured captain Craig Bellamy, who'd blasted his side after the Finland defeat.
Encouragingly for Wales, Arsenal teenage midfielder Ramsey did not look out of his depth against Germany but he was powerless to prevent Chelsea's Ballack letting fly with a dipping shot which gave keeper Wayne Hennessey no chance.
Wales though were unlucky not to have a spot-kick in the 26th minute after Gareth Bale and Joe Ledley combined down the left wing.
Tasci stumbled as he backed off the advancing Ledley inside the box and the defender's hand made contact with the ball. It seemed a penalty but Norway's Hauge dismissed Wales's appeals.
Hennessey had to save well from both Thomas Hitzlsperger and Lukas Podolski to prevent Germany doubling their lead and it wasn't until after half-time they added a second goal.
Mario Gomez managed to send in a speculative cross and Williams, sticking out a leg, diverted the ball into his own net.
This was Germany's second win in five days after they'd swept aside Liechtenstein and manager Joachim Loew said: "It was extremely important that we won these two games.
"We now have 16 points from 18 in this group with four games left. That means I am absolutely content with the situation."
Loew also brushed aside an on-field row between Ballack and Lukas Podolski in the second half which only ended after the referee intervened.
"I have not had the chance to talk to them about it, but if a captain gives out orders on the pitch it is the duty of any players to carry them out."
|Coach: J. Toshack|
for S. Ricketts 54'
for S. Vokes 63'
for L. Nyatanga 75'
|Serie A Review: El Shaarawy at the double in Milan victory, Fiorentina edge five-goal thriller|
|Taylor close to signing new Swansea contract|
|Milan 3 Torino 0: El Shaarawy grabs brace as Inzaghi´s men ease to victory|
|Bruce expresses sympathy with Hull owner and fans following relegation|
|Preston North End 4 Swindon Town 0: Beckford hat-trick seals promotion|
|Darmstadt promoted back to the Bundesliga after 33-year exile|
|Sherwood to assess Given injury ahead of FA Cup final|
|Europa League qualification would cap ´special´ season - Koeman|
|South Africa 0 Botswana 0 (6-7 on penalties): Hosts exit COSAFA Cup at first hurdle|
|Pearson hopeful of Cambiasso stay|
|Ings emotional after victorious ´last game´|
|Pochettino happy to finish fifth|
|West Brom release Mulumbu|
|Monk: Palace defeat not a reflection on season|
|LVG awaits news on ´minor´ Di Maria injury, refuses to comment on Falcao exit reports|
|Pulis accepts blame for West Brom´s Arsenal collapse|
|Toure and Milner were not saying goodbye - Pellegrini|
|Ramsey calls for patience in QPR rebuild|
|Allardyce: Time is right for West Ham exit|
|Mourinho already preparing for title defence|
|Eredivisie Review: Heerenveen to play Vitesse for Europa League place|
|Hughes hails Stoke showing|
|Carver still hoping to land Newcastle job|
|Sunderland squad needs better balance, says Advocaat|
|Pardew ´never dreamt´ of top-half finish at Palace|
|Survival Sunday: How the final-day Premier League relegation battle played out|
|Arsenal wanted Walcott stay regardless of hat-trick - Wenger|
|Bruce: Hull have not been good enough|
|De Gea has to say something - Van Gaal|
|Rodgers apologises after ´embarrassing´ defeat|
|Chelsea 3 Sunderland 1: Remy double secures win as Drogba bids farewell|
|Stoke City 6 Liverpool 1: Gerrard nets consolation in final-game thrashing|
|West Ham confirm Allardyce exit|
|Newcastle United 2 West Ham 0: Gutierrez on target as Carver´s men stay up|
|Crystal Palace 1 Swansea City 0: Chamakh earns season-closing win|
|Manchester City 2 Southampton 0: Lampard bids Premier League farewell with goal|
|Hull City 0 Manchester United 0: Bruce´s men relegated|
|Aston Villa 0 Burnley 1: Ings heads winner|
|Everton 0 Tottenham 1: Kane header seals fifth place|
|Leicester City 5 QPR 1: Vardy celebrates England call-up in style|
|Arsenal 4 West Brom 1: Wilshere screamer and trio for Theo secures third|
|Drogba carried from the pitch by Chelsea team-mates|
|Scottish Premiership Review: United take Dundee derby spoils, Celtic smash Inverness|
|Ashley not leaving Newcastle until club wins something|
|Klopp urges fans not to draw comparisons with Tuchel|
|Dortmund complete Castro capture|
|Stevens leaves Stuttgart after securing safety|
|Alves ruled out of Copa with serious knee injury|
|Drogba to leave Chelsea|
|Ashley is from another planet - Keegan|
|Sydney withdraw Janko offer amid talk of Toni|
|Cameron pens Stoke extension|
|Wimmer: I´m going to Tottenham|
|Returning Grabban ready for play-off final - Neil|
|Ferdinand ´overwhelmed´ by support following wife´s death|
|Odegaard enjoys ´nervous´ Real Madrid debut|
|Bamford fit but may be overlooked for play-off final|
|Barcelona´s best better than Real´s - Luis Enrique|
|Ancelotti laments key injuries in title failure|
|AFC Champions League Preview: Evergrande, Al Hilal desperate for wins|
|MLS Review: DC United deny nine-man Revolution, Rapids break drought|
|Bielsa hints at Marseille departure, congratulates Ligue 1|
|Silva, Matuidi eye fourth trophy|
|Jonas deserved golden boot - Jorge Jesus|
|Primeira Liga Review: Benfica celebrate title with home win|
|Ligue 1 Review: Monaco seal final Champions League spot, Marseille take fourth|
|Ancelotti to take sabbatical if sacked by Real|
|Mancini annoyed by ´absurd´ Inter mistakes|
|Simeone hails ´incredible season´|
|Replacing Xavi will be impossible - Luis Enrique|
|Ronaldo hopes Ancelotti will stay|
|Guardiola: We´ll be back stronger|
|Paris Saint-Germain 3 Reims 2: Cavani double sees champions celebrate title with routine win|
|Garitano stands down following Eibar relegation|
|Genoa 3 Inter 2: Kucka strikes blow to visitors´ Europa quest|
|Real Madrid 7 Getafe 3: Ronaldo nets treble and Odegaard makes history|
|Southend United 1 Wycombe Wanderers 1 (aet, 7-6 on penalties): Last-gasp Pigott and Bentley the hero|
|Odegaard becomes Real´s youngest player|
|Gargano omitted from Uruguay Copa America squad|
|La Liga Review: Depor save themselves with stunning comeback at Barca|
|Barcelona 2 Deportivo La Coruna 2: Salomao saves visitors as Xavi bids Camp Nou farewell|
|Granada 0 Atletico Madrid 0: Atleti secure third as hosts survive|
|Juventus 3 Napoli 1: Champions turn on the style|
|Tearful Klopp struggled to say goodbye|
|Scottish Premiership Review: Rangers to meet Motherwell in play-off final|
|Bundesliga Review: Freiburg and Paderborn relegated|
|Borussia Dortmund 3 Werder Bremen 2: Dortmund seal European spot as Klopp says farewell|
|Bayern Munich 2 Mainz 0: Schweinsteiger nets as champions celebrate title|
|Championship play-off final Preview: Karanka and Neil eye swift ascent to Premier League|
|Volland commits to Hoffenheim|
|Monk: Michu likely to move on|
|Allardyce not interested in Newcastle revenge|
|Sherwood confident of Benteke Villa stay|
|Rodgers calls on Liverpool fans to support Sterling|
|Khedira ´frozen out´ by Real|
|Hamstring injury rules Suarez out of Deportivo clash|
|Former Southampton managers hail ´excellent season´|
|Mourinho wants to remain in England after Chelsea|
|Rodgers ´150 per cent sure´ his job is safe|
|Maldini would ´love´ to help Milan|
|Doyle set for Rapids debut versus Whitecaps|
|MLS Review: Champions end winless run on day of late drama|
|Jemez doubted Rayo future|
|Zenga could replace Mihajlovic - Osti|
|Blanc wants to avoid Chelsea-like finish|
|Menez happy in Milan|
|Sherwood: Vlaar wants to stay|
|Arsenal v West Brom: Wenger calls for focus|